Differences Between Jelly Roll Pans and Cookie Baking Sheets

Understand the differences between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets. Learn how to make the most of each type of pan for baking cookies, cakes and other delicious treats.

Are you confused about the differences between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets?

With all the types of pans available for baking, it’s easy to get overwhelmed when deciding which is best for the task. Knowing the differences between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets can help you decide when to select the right pan for your baking needs.

As an experienced home baker and owner of a bakery, I understand the nuances between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets. In this article, I will explain the differences between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets, so you can decide which is best for your baking needs.

By this article’s end, you’ll better understand these two types of baking pans and how to use them correctly. So read on to learn more about the distinctions between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets.

What is a Jelly Roll Pan?

A jelly roll pan is a type of baking pan that is typically 10×15 inches in size and has a rimmed edge. It is commonly used for baking rolled cakes, brownies, bars, and pies.

A cookie baking sheet is a flat, rectangular baking pan with no edges. It is designed specifically for baking cookies and is larger than a regular baking pan, allowing more cookies to be baked at once. Cookie baking sheets are also known as cookie sheets or baking sheets.

Yoy may like to know information about difference between Baking Pan and Cookie Sheet.

What are the Common Uses of Each Type of Pan?

Jelly roll pans are most commonly used for baking jelly rolls, cakes, bars, and other desserts that require containment. They can also be used to roast vegetables or bake casseroles.

Cookie baking sheets are primarily used for baking cookies but can also roast vegetables or bake other small desserts such as scones or muffins.

FeatureJelly Roll PanCookie Baking Sheet
SizeTypically around 10 x 15 inchesTypically around 14 x 17 inches
Depth1 inch1/4 inch
UsesSuitable for baking jelly roll cakes and rolled pastries, as well as for roasting vegetablesSuitable for baking cookies, as well as for roasting and toasting nuts and seeds
RimHas a rim around the edges to contain batter or fillingRimless or has very low rim
SurfaceNon-stick surfaceCan be non-stick or uncoated
Jelly Roll Pan vs Cookie Sheets

How Do You Choose the Right Pan?

When choosing between a jelly roll pan and a cookie baking sheet, it’s essential to consider the type of recipe you are making and the size of your oven. If you need to bake something that requires containment (such as a cake or jelly roll), you should opt for a jelly roll pan. However, if you are making cookies or another small dessert that does not require containment, you should opt for a cookie baking sheet.

For larger recipes such as cakes and casseroles, you may consider using two jelly roll pans instead of one large one. This will help ensure even baking and prevent burning or undercooking in certain areas of the pan.


Understanding the differences between jelly roll pans and cookie baking sheets can help ensure that your baked goods come out perfectly every time! Jelly roll pans are best suited for baking cakes, bars, and other desserts that require containment, while cookie baking sheets are best suited for baking small treats such as cookies and scones. When deciding which type of pan to use for your recipe, you must consider the size of your oven and the recipe you are making. With this information in mind, you’ll be able to make an informed decision and get great results every time!


Can I use a cookie sheet instead of a jelly roll pan?

A cookie sheet can be a substitute for a jelly roll pan, as long as it has rims at least a half-inch high. However, it is essential to note that the cake will be thinner than desired if the proper pan is not used for baking.

Is a jelly roll pan the same size as a half sheet pan?

A jelly roll pan is smaller than a half sheet pan, measuring 15×10″ with 1″-high sides. It is ideal for baking cakes, cookies, and other desserts that require a shallow baking pan. The half sheet pan is larger, measuring 18×13″, and is excellent for baking larger items such as roasts, vegetables, and breads.

What is the difference between a sheet pan and a cookie sheet?

A cookie sheet is a flat baking sheet with no sides or lips, while a baking sheet has a rim around the edge. This rim makes it easier to grip with potholders but can make removing cookies from the sheet more difficult. A cookie sheet is ideal for baking cookies, while a baking sheet is better for roasting vegetables or baking other items that don’t require removal from the sheet.

Share your love

Meet Fuad, the passionate baker behind Bakingbakewaresets Blog. With years of experience, Fuad shares his favorite recipes, baking tips, and recommendations for the best bakeware sets. His goal is to help readers achieve success in their baking endeavors, whether they're beginners or experienced bakers.