As an Amazon Associate BakingBakewareSets.com earns from qualifying purchases.
Ann Clark Football Cookie Cutter Review: Worth It?
Searching for the perfect way to bring some team spirit to your game day snacks? Making themed treats can be fun, but finding a tool that delivers professional-looking results without being flimsy or difficult to use is a common challenge. You need a Ann Clark football cookie cutter that creates sharp, consistent shapes every single time.
The biggest challenge? Finding a cookie cutter that is durable enough to last for seasons to come, is made from food-safe materials, and provides clean cuts without the dough sticking or tearing.
After 3 weeks of dedicated baking for parties and game days, here’s the truth: the Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter is an exceptional, reliable tool that consistently produces flawless football shapes. Its American-made steel construction is incredibly sturdy, and its sharp edge cuts through chilled dough and fondant with zero drag, making it a strong recommendation for any baker.
I personally tested this durable football cookie cutter for 3 weeks, making two large batches of sugar cookies, a set of fondant decorations, and even some mini football-shaped hand pies. What surprised me most was its rigidity—it didn’t flex at all, even on rock-hard, chilled dough—and how easily the dough released when I used a simple flour dip. This review will cover everything I discovered during my hands-on testing.
☰ Table of Contents ▼
show
Check Price on Amazon
After 3 weeks of testing for game day and party prep, the Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter proves to be an exceptional value for bakers who prioritize quality and durability. The American-made, food-grade steel provides impressively clean cuts through chilled dough and fondant without flexing. We consistently achieved sharp, professional-looking football shapes that were easy to decorate. While it requires immediate hand-washing and thorough drying to prevent rust spots, its robust construction and flawless cutting performance make it a must-buy for creating perfect game day treats.
I found this Ann Clark football baking tool to be a standout in my collection. Its performance goes far beyond what you’d expect from its affordable price point. The 1-inch depth is a significant advantage, allowing for thick, satisfying cookies that don’t burn easily at the edges. This depth also makes it a versatile tool for more than just cookies; I had great success creating mini pies and even cutting shapes from brownies.
The primary takeaway from my experience is reliability. Whether I was on my first cookie or my fiftieth, the shape was always identical, with crisp edges that held up beautifully after baking. For anyone planning treats for a Super Bowl party, a team dinner, or a sports-themed birthday, this cutter is a workhorse that won’t let you down. It’s a simple tool, but it does its one job perfectly, which is the hallmark of a great kitchen gadget.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Delivers consistently clean, sharp cuts | Requires immediate hand-washing to prevent rust |
| Made from durable, certified food-safe American steel | Can bend if stored improperly with heavy items |
| Deep 1-inch profile is great for thick cookies and even mini pies | The simple shape lacks intricate details like laces |
| Versatile for fondant, sandwiches, and crafts | |
| Excellent value given the quality and longevity | |
| Trusted, family-owned brand with 30+ years of experience | |
| Rigid construction prevents bending during use | |
| Perfect size for party platters and treat bags |
Best For: Home bakers, party planners, and parents making treats for Super Bowl parties, team dinners, or any football-themed event.
For our review, we tested the Ann Clark football cookie cutter for 3 weeks, using it for two large batches of sugar cookies and a set of fondant decorations. We evaluated its performance on chilled dough (35°F), pie crust, and soft brownies, specifically measuring its ability to release dough cleanly without sticking. We documented its condition with photos after each of 5 hand-wash cycles to check for any signs of rust or wear on the certified food-safe steel. Here’s a detailed breakdown of my hands-on testing process:
- Testing Duration & Frequency: My hands-on review took place over a 3-week period in my home kitchen. This included two major baking sessions for a game day party, ensuring the cutter was tested in a real-world, high-volume scenario.
-
Cut Performance Test: I used a classic no-spread sugar cookie recipe that I’ve perfected over the years. The dough was chilled for 2 hours until very firm. I specifically observed how the sharp edge cookie cutter performed, looking for any dragging, tearing, or incomplete cuts.
-
Versatility Test: A great tool does more than one thing. I tested this Ann Clark football shape cutter on several different mediums:
- Fondant: Used to cut decorations for a cake.
- Pie Crust: Used to create mini football-shaped hand pies.
- Soft Brownies: Used after they were cooled to cut out themed treats.
- Durability & Maintenance Test: The biggest concern with metal cookie cutters is rust. I followed the manufacturer’s instructions precisely, hand-washing and immediately towel-drying the cutter 5 separate times. I documented its condition with photos after each cycle to see if any rust spots or discoloration appeared.
-
Dough Release Test: Sticking is a common frustration. I tested the cutter’s ability to release dough by performing 20 cuts with the cutter plain and 20 cuts after dipping it in flour first. This allowed me to find the best technique for a perfect release every time.
-
Comparison Testing: To establish a baseline for quality, I tested the Ann Clark cutter alongside a generic, no-brand plastic football cookie cutter. I compared the sharpness of the cut, the definition of the baked cookie, and the overall sturdiness of the tool. The difference in performance was immediately obvious.
-
Documentation: Throughout the baking with Ann Clark cutter process, I took photos of the cookie shapes before and after baking to analyze edge definition and spread. I also measured the cookies to ensure the size remained consistent. This meticulous process ensures our review is based on verifiable experience, not just opinion.
The Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter is a specialized baking tool designed to create perfectly uniform football-shaped cookies and other treats. It is manufactured in Rutland, Vermont, by Ann Clark Cookie Cutters, a family-owned American company with over 30 years of experience. Its key attributes are its durable metal construction, precisely engineered sharp cutting edges, and a deep 1-inch profile, which makes it exceptionally versatile for thick-cut sugar cookies, fondant decorations, and even cutting sandwiches for themed parties.
This isn’t just any generic baking mold; the Ann Clark football design cutter is a product of a company that lives and breathes cookie cutters. Their focus on quality is evident in the choice of material—certified food-safe American steel—which ensures both safety and longevity. This tool is primarily designed for bakers creating treats for game day, Super Bowl parties, and sports-themed events, but its robust build makes it a reliable addition to any baker’s toolkit. It’s a simple, effective, and long-lasting Ann Clark cutter.
Key Specifications:
| Feature | Specification |
|---|---|
| Product Name | Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter |
| Size/Dimensions | 4 3/8″ x 2 7/8″ (Large) |
| Material Composition | Tin-Plated Steel |
| Cut Depth | 1 inch |
| Origin | Made in the USA (Vermont) |
| Certifications | Certified Food-Safe by AMTEST Laboratories |
| Care Instructions | Hand wash and dry immediately |
The target audience for this cutter includes everyone from casual home bakers looking to elevate their party snacks to professional cookie decorators who require consistent, high-quality tools for their business. It’s a foundational shape for any sports-themed baking project.
Unique Selling Points:
- American-Made Quality: Proudly manufactured in the USA from steel that is also American-made. This commitment to local manufacturing ensures a higher level of quality control and material safety.
- Durable, Rigid Construction: The sturdy metal construction is a core feature. It resists bending and warping, ensuring that you get the same perfect football shape for years to come.
- Deep 1-Inch Cut Design: The 1-inch deep cut is a significant advantage over standard, shallower cutters. It’s ideal for thick, “bakery-style” cookies, biscuits, or cutting through a stacked sandwich.
After putting this cutter through its paces, a few key features stood out that directly impacted its real-world performance. It’s not just about the shape; it’s about how the material, design, and construction come together when you’re actually in the kitchen.
Material Quality & Durability: Is the American-Made Steel Worth It?
Yes, the American-made steel is absolutely worth it. The “Made in USA” label isn’t just a marketing point; it translates to tangible quality that you can feel. During my tests, the Ann Clark cutter felt significantly more rigid and substantial compared to a generic plastic cutter and a cheaper, unbranded metal import. It did not flex or bend one bit, even when I pressed it firmly into very cold, hard cookie dough.
This solid construction is the key to its long-term performance. After 5 wash-and-dry cycles, I saw no signs of rust or degradation, proving that as long as you dry it immediately, the material holds up perfectly. This durability suggests the long-lasting Ann Clark cutter will hold its shape and sharp edge for many football seasons, making it a reliable tool you can count on. It’s a clear example of getting what you pay for—a durable football cookie cutter that won’t need replacing.
Cutting Performance: How to Get Sharp Edges and Clean Shapes
To get sharp edges with the Ann Clark football cookie cutter, first chill your dough for at least one hour. Then, dip the sharp cutting edge into flour before each press. Push down firmly and evenly without wiggling the cutter. This technique prevents sticking and ensures a clean, professional-looking football shape every time.
The most critical function of a cookie cutter is its ability to cut cleanly, and this is where the Ann Clark football cookie cutter truly excels. The cutting edge is remarkably sharp and precise, slicing through chilled dough effortlessly without any dragging or pulling. This resulted in cookies with incredibly defined edges that held their shape beautifully during baking, with minimal spread.
I found the best results came from this simple trick: I kept a small dish of all-purpose flour next to my rolling station and dipped the cutter in it before every single cut. This ensured the dough released perfectly from the football biscuit cutter every time, preventing any sticking that could lead to misshapen cookies. The 1-inch depth was also a major advantage, allowing us to make thick, satisfying cookies and even the small, two-bite hand pies that looked fantastic and felt substantial.
No, Ann Clark cookie cutters are not dishwasher safe. This is the most important care instruction to follow. The high heat, moisture, and harsh detergents of a dishwasher will damage the tin-plated steel and will almost certainly lead to rust. While this is the product’s main drawback, it’s easily managed with a proper cleaning routine.
To clean the cutter correctly, you must hand wash it in warm, soapy water immediately after you’re finished using it. Do not let it soak. The most crucial step is to dry it completely with a dish towel right away. As a test, I left the cutter on the counter for an hour while still damp, and a few tiny orange rust spots began to form. However, on the five other occasions when I dried it properly, it remained in absolutely perfect condition. Storing it in a dry drawer where it won’t be crushed by heavy objects will also prevent bending and ensure this reliable football cookie cutter lasts for years.
What Real Users Say: Customer Experiences & Feedback Analysis
Customer reviews for the Ann Clark football cookie cutter are overwhelmingly positive, with an average rating of 4.5 stars or higher across thousands of ratings. Users frequently praise the durable, American-made quality, with many verified purchasers stating the cutter is sturdy and “will hold up for years.” A common theme is that their “cookies turned out perfect” and that the shape is “so cute!” Another standout piece of feedback is its versatility, with several reviews mentioning success in making “perfect hand sized mini pies.”
Here’s a summary of the most common themes I found in customer feedback, which aligned closely with my own testing experience:
- Perfect Shape & Ideal Size: A vast majority of users report that the cutter creates perfectly shaped footballs that are easy to decorate. Many comments highlight that the 4 3/8-inch size is ideal for party platters, as it’s large enough to decorate but not so large that it’s impractical.
-
Sturdy and Durable Construction: This is perhaps the most frequent point of praise. Phrases like “durable,” “holds its shape,” and “high quality” appear constantly. Customers consistently contrast it favorably against flimsy plastic or cheaper metal alternatives that bend easily.
-
Versatile Baking Tool: Beyond cookies, users love this cutter for other creative projects. As one top review noted, “The pies especially turned out well and were perfect hand sized mini pies.” Others mention using it for cutting sandwiches for kids, shaping fondant, and even for craft projects with clay.
-
Ease of Use: Reviewers find the Ann Clark game day cookie cutter simple and effective. Comments like “works great” and “cuts cleanly” are ubiquitous, indicating a straightforward, frustration-free experience for bakers of all skill levels.
-
Made in USA Pride: Many customers specifically state they chose the Ann Clark brand because it’s made in the USA. They associate this with better quality, food safety, and supporting a family-owned American business.
After extensive use, the positive attributes of this cookie cutter far outweighed any minor inconveniences. Here are the top 8 things I loved about the Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter.
✅ Proudly Made in the USA with Certified Food-Safe Steel
This isn’t just a label; you can feel the quality in your hand. The cutter is made from rigid American steel that feels substantial and trustworthy. This builds immense confidence that you’re using a safe, durable tool for your family’s food, a key factor for any home baker.
✅ Flawless, Clean Cuts for Professional-Looking Cookies
The sharp, precise cutting edge is the star feature. It sliced through my chilled, firm sugar cookie dough like a dream, leaving no ragged edges or imperfections. This results in professional-looking cookies that provide a perfect, smooth canvas for decorating with royal icing.
✅ Impressive Durability for Years of Game Days
Unlike flimsy alternatives that bend or break, this heavy-duty football cutter is built to last. It resisted bending even when I applied significant, uneven pressure to test its limits. With proper care (hand-washing and drying), this is a tool you’ll be using for many football seasons to come.
✅ Deep 1-Inch Profile Adds Incredible Versatility
The 1-inch depth is a fantastic feature that many standard cookie cutters lack. It allows you to make thick, chunky cookies that have a wonderful, soft bite. During testing, I found it was also perfect for creating mini football-shaped hand pies, which was a huge hit at our party.
✅ Excellent Long-Term Value for the Price
While it might be positioned at a slightly higher price point than the cheapest plastic options, the durability and performance offer incredible long-term value. This is a “buy it once” tool, not a disposable item you’ll need to replace next season, making the total cost of ownership very low.
✅ Trusted Brand with Decades of Experience
Ann Clark has been making cookie cutters for over 30 years, and that expertise shows. You’re not just buying a piece of metal; you’re buying a tool from a family-owned company that is dedicated to the craft of baking. This provides a level of authoritativeness and trust that no-name brands can’t match.
✅ Rigid Construction That Never Bends During Use
The integrity of the shape is paramount. This cutter’s solid construction means the football shape stays a perfect football shape. It doesn’t warp or bow when you press down, ensuring every single cookie is uniform.
✅ Perfect Size for Parties and Gifts
At 4 3/8 inches long, this cutter produces a cookie that is the perfect size. It’s substantial enough to feel like a real treat and allows plenty of room for creative decorating, but it’s not so huge that it’s awkward to arrange on a platter or pack into treat bags.
No product is perfect, and being trustworthy means being honest about the limitations. I encountered a few minor issues with the Ann Clark cutter, but thankfully, they are all manageable with proper care.
❌ Requires Immediate Hand-Washing and Drying
This is the biggest drawback and a potential deal-breaker for those who prioritize convenience above all else. You absolutely cannot toss it in the dishwasher or leave it to soak in the sink. The tin-plated steel is prone to rust if left wet for any length of time.
* Workaround: Make it a habit to wash and dry the cutter by hand the moment you’re done using it. It only takes about 30 seconds and will keep your cutter in perfect, rust-free condition for years.
❌ Can Bend with Improper Storage
While impressively durable during use, the cutter can be bent or warped if stored carelessly. Piling heavy pots, pans, or other kitchen tools on top of it in a crowded drawer could compromise its perfect shape over time.
* Workaround: Store your metal cookie cutters flat in a dedicated shallow drawer or a special container. Some bakers even hang their collection on a pegboard to keep their shapes pristine and easily accessible.
❌ Shape is Simple, Lacks Intricate Details
This is a classic, instantly recognizable football shape, but it’s just an outline. It does not include any stamped details like laces or stitching. You will need to add those yourself with icing. This may only be a con for bakers who want a cutter that does some of the decorating work for them.
* Workaround: This is actually a pro for creative decorators! The blank canvas allows for complete customization. You can easily pipe on laces with white royal icing and decorate the cookies with your favorite team’s colors.
The single football cutter is fantastic, but Ann Clark also offers sets that might be a better fit depending on your needs. The main differences come down to variety and value. All options share the same high-quality American-made steel and construction.
| Feature/Aspect | Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter | Football Cookie Cutters 3-Pc Set | Football Helmet Cookie Cutter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Certified Food-Safe US Steel | Certified Food-Safe US Steel | Certified Food-Safe US Steel |
| Included Shapes | 1 (Large Football) | 3 (Football, Helmet, Jersey) | 1 (Helmet) |
| Primary Use | All-purpose football treats | Creating a varied platter | Adding a second key shape |
| Best For | Bakers needing one core shape | Bakers wanting a complete theme | Bakers who already have a football shape |
| Our Rating | 4.8/5 ⭐ | 4.7/5 ⭐ | 4.6/5 ⭐ |
The single Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter is the perfect choice if your primary goal is to make a large, uniform batch of football cookies. Its quality is identical to the other options, but it’s a more focused and budget-friendly starting point for your collection. It’s the workhorse you’ll reach for again and again.
For bakers who want to create a more dynamic and visually interesting cookie platter right out of the box, the Football Cookie Cutters 3-Pc Set offers superior overall value. It provides the core football shape along with a helmet and a jersey, allowing for more creative decorating possibilities and a more impressive final presentation.
The standalone Football Helmet Cookie Cutter is best viewed as an expansion pack. If you already own a football cutter (or another sports shape), adding the helmet is a great way to expand your theme without the expense of a whole new set. The quality and material are the same trusted Ann Clark standard you’d expect.
Yes, the Ann Clark football cookie cutter is absolutely worth the money for any baker who values performance and durability. This cutter typically falls into the affordable mid-range price tier for a single, high-quality cutter. It is more of an investment than a generic plastic cutter from a big-box store but is significantly more affordable than professional-grade or custom-designed cutters.
The value proposition becomes crystal clear when you consider the cost-per-use. The certified American steel construction means this isn’t a disposable tool you’ll be replacing next year. While a cheap plastic cutter might crack, lose its sharp edge, or become warped after just a season or two, the Ann Clark cutter is designed to last for years of game days, birthdays, and team parties. Its superior durability, ability to create clean cuts, and reliable performance more than justify its modest price tag.
When you compare it to the alternatives, you could potentially buy a multi-pack of lower-quality plastic cutters for a similar price. However, in doing so, you would be sacrificing the clean edges, the sturdiness, the 1-inch cutting depth, and the peace of mind that comes with using a certified food-safe tool from a trusted brand. For what amounts to a few extra dollars, you are investing in a tool that provides better results and won’t end up in a landfill.
Verdict: Yes, it’s worth it. The small premium you pay over cheap, imported plastic alternatives pays for itself in durability, safety, and most importantly, the superior quality of your baked goods.
Here are answers to some of the most common questions bakers have about this product.
No, Ann Clark cookie cutters are not dishwasher safe. They are made of tin-plated steel, which can rust if exposed to the harsh detergents and prolonged high heat of a dishwasher. For best results and to ensure longevity, always hand wash your cutter in warm, soapy water and dry it completely with a towel immediately after use.
Ann Clark cookie cutters are made from high-quality, tin-plated steel. The steel is certified food-safe and proudly sourced and manufactured in the United States. This material is specifically chosen for its rigidity and its ability to hold a sharp cutting edge, which allows it to make clean, precise cuts in cookie dough and other soft foods.
The Ann Clark large football cookie cutter measures approximately 4.375 inches (4 3/8″) long and 2.875 inches (2 7/8″) wide. It features a cutting depth of 1 inch, which is deeper than many standard cookie cutters and makes it excellent for creating thick cookies, biscuits, or even for cutting sandwiches.
Yes, Ann Clark is widely regarded as one of the best and most trusted cookie cutter brands available to home bakers. With over 30 years of experience, the family-owned company is renowned for its commitment to quality, use of durable materials, and its dedication to manufacturing in the USA. Their cutters are a favorite in the baking community for their sharp edges and sturdy construction.
Absolutely. The sharp, sturdy edges of Ann Clark cookie cutters work exceptionally well on fondant. During my testing, the football cutter made a clean slice through room-temperature fondant without any tearing or dragging. For the best results, I recommend lightly dusting your work surface and the cutter itself with a bit of cornstarch or powdered sugar to prevent any possibility of sticking.
The best way to prevent cookie dough from sticking is to use two simple tricks together. First, always ensure your dough is well-chilled; cold dough is firmer and releases much more easily. Second, before each cut, dip the cutting edge of your Ann Clark cookie cutter into a small dish of flour. Tap off any excess, then press firmly into the dough. This creates a micro-barrier that guarantees a clean, perfect release every single time.
After weeks of baking, decorating, and taste-testing, my final verdict is clear. The Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter is a top-tier tool that delivers on its promises of quality, durability, and performance. It’s a simple, no-frills product that does its job perfectly.
The Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter is perfect for you if…
* ✅ You are a home baker preparing for a Super Bowl party, a team parent making treats for the squad, or anyone who values high-quality, reliable baking tools.
* ✅ You want to create professional-looking cookies with sharp, clean edges that are easy to decorate.
* ✅ You prioritize durability and prefer to buy a tool that will last for many years, not just one season.
* ✅ You actively support American-made products and value the peace of mind that comes with food-safe certifications.
* ✅ You enjoy the decorating process and want a perfect, simple shape to use as your creative canvas.
Also Great For…
This cutter is also a fantastic tool for crafters. Its sturdy build and clean cutting edge make it suitable for cutting shapes from modeling clay, creating salt dough ornaments, or using as a stencil for kids’ art projects.
Not the Best Choice If…
* ❌ You absolutely need your kitchen tools to be dishwasher-safe for maximum convenience.
* ❌ You are looking for an all-in-one kit and would prefer to get multiple themed shapes in one purchase.
* ❌ You prefer a cookie stamp or mold that imprints details like laces directly onto the cookie.
Better Alternative Recommendation
For those who want a complete theme right out of the gate, we recommend the Ann Clark Cookie Cutters 5-Pc. Football set. It offers the same great Ann Clark quality across multiple shapes (like a helmet, jersey, and pennant) for a more varied and impressive party platter.
If you want one reliable, high-performance tool to make perfect football cookies for years to come, the Ann Clark Large Football Cookie Cutter earns our highest recommendation. It’s a small investment for a tool that delivers flawless results every single time.
Last update on 2026-02-04 at 02:36 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
