As an Amazon Associate BakingBakewareSets.com earns from qualifying purchases.
A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles Review: Worth It for Baking?
☰ Table of Contents ▼
show
A Great Surprise vegan sprinkles review 2026: Our Honest Verdict After 3 Weeks
Check Price on Amazon
After 3 weeks of decorating everything from vegan cupcakes to ice cream, A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles prove to be a top-tier healthier alternative for bakers. The vibrant, plant-based colors hold up surprisingly well without bleeding, and their distinctly soft texture and pleasant taste—free from any weird artificial aftertaste—make them a clear winner for anyone avoiding artificial dyes and animal products. While they lack the classic crunch, their clean ingredients and guilt-free indulgence make them worth it for health-conscious families.
As a baker who is always on the lookout for high-quality, clean-label ingredients, finding good vegan sprinkles can be a real challenge. Many “natural” options have dull colors, a strange taste, or bleed all over your frosting. The A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles, however, caught my attention with their promise of vibrant colors from plant-based ingredients. I was skeptical but hopeful that they could be the healthier alternative I’d been searching for.
Over 21 days of hands-on testing, I put these plant-based jimmies through their paces in my kitchen. My goal was simple: to see if they could deliver a fun, colorful, and tasty experience without the artificial junk. I was most concerned about three things: taste (no artificial aftertaste), color stability (no bleeding), and texture. The results were genuinely surprising and have made these a new staple in my pantry. They offer a fantastic balance of clean ingredients and joyful dessert decoration, making them a standout in the natural sprinkles market.
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Truly vibrant colors from natural, plant-based sources | Softer texture may disappoint those who prefer a traditional crunch |
| No artificial aftertaste, just a pleasant, sweet flavor | Colors are slightly less glossy than dye-filled alternatives |
| Soft texture that melts in your mouth, ideal for kids | Premium positioning compared to conventional sprinkles |
| Certified Vegan, non-GMO, and gluten-friendly | |
| Performs well in baking with minimal color bleed | |
| Available in large, resealable bulk containers | |
| Great for those with dietary sensitivities | |
| Clean, simple ingredient list |
Best For: Health-conscious parents, vegan bakers, and anyone with dietary sensitivities looking for a clean-label, dye-free dessert topping.
Why Trust Our A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles Review? How We Tested
To provide an authentic and hands-on sprinkles review, I personally purchased and tested the A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles over a 3-week period. This wasn’t just a quick look; I integrated these sprinkles into my regular baking and dessert-making routine to see how they performed under real-world kitchen conditions. My testing methodology was designed to verify the brand’s claims and uncover any potential drawbacks.
For our verified vegan product testing, my evaluation focused on four key areas: color vibrancy and stability, taste and aftertaste, texture, and overall performance when baked or applied to moist surfaces. I meticulously documented my findings, taking photos before and after each test to provide clear, visual evidence of their performance.
Here’s a breakdown of my A Great Surprise sprinkles testing methodology:
- Testing Duration & Frequency: The sprinkles were tested for 21 consecutive days. I used them on desserts 4-5 times per week to get a comprehensive understanding of their versatility and performance over time.
- Testing Environment: All tests were conducted in my standard home kitchen, using common appliances and recipes to simulate a typical user experience.
- Specific Scenarios Tested: I created four distinct tests to push the sprinkles to their limits.
- Topping Test: I generously applied the sprinkles to fresh buttercream frosting on vegan cupcakes and left them at room temperature for a full 24 hours. This was to check for any color bleed onto the white frosting and to see if the texture changed over time.
- Baking Test: I mixed the sprinkles directly into a vegan sugar cookie batter to create a “funfetti” style cookie. The cookies were baked at 350°F to evaluate the color-fastness, shape retention, and melting point of the sprinkles when exposed to high heat.
- Frozen Test: The sprinkles were stirred into a pint of vanilla bean vegan ice cream and then re-frozen for several hours. This test was designed to assess their texture when frozen and to check for immediate color bleed in a high-moisture, cold environment.
- Moisture Test: Finally, I sprinkled them over a bowl of plain, plant-based yogurt. This allowed me to observe how the natural colors reacted to a moist and slightly acidic surface.
- Comparison Products: To provide a fair baseline, I compared their performance directly against standard, non-vegan rainbow sprinkles from a popular grocery store brand. This helped highlight the differences in taste, texture, and color vibrancy.
- Documentation Methods: I kept a detailed journal of my observations, noting the taste, texture, and any hint of aftertaste. High-resolution photos were taken at each stage to document the results, especially regarding color bleed and vibrancy after baking.
What Are A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles? Product Overview & Specifications
A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles are a type of dessert decoration, known as rainbow jimmies, specifically created as a healthier alternative to the conventional sprinkles found in most stores. Their main function is to provide a vibrant, colorful, and fun topping for baked goods like cakes and cookies, as well as frozen treats, without the use of artificial dyes, animal byproducts, or common allergens. They are part of a growing category of plant-based dessert toppings designed for the modern, health-conscious consumer.
What makes these natural dessert decorations stand out is their commitment to a clean label. The brand, A Great Surprise, uses natural colorings derived from plant and vegetable sources instead of synthetic, petroleum-based dyes like Red 40 or Yellow 5. This makes them a form of guilt-free indulgence for consumers with specific dietary needs or for parents who are careful about what they feed their children. Made from simple ingredients like sugar, cornstarch, and vegetable oil, they are marketed directly to vegan bakers, families, and anyone looking for allergy-friendly ingredients.
Key Specifications
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Ingredients | Sugar, Cornstarch, Vegetable Oil, and Natural Colorants. Free from artificial dyes and flavors. |
| Dietary Compliance | Vegan, Non-GMO, Gluten-Friendly, Kosher. |
| Texture | Soft texture, not crunchy. Melts in the mouth. |
| Color Source | Natural colors derived from fruits and vegetables like spirulina, turmeric, and beet root. |
| Packaging | Available in various sizes, including bulk 1.6 lb and 2.2 lb resealable containers. |
| Common Uses | Topping for ice cream, cupcakes, cookies; mixing into batter for a funfetti effect. |
Who Are They For?
The target audience for these sprinkles is broad and includes:
* Vegans and those on a plant-based diet.
* Parents of young children who want to avoid artificial food dyes.
* Individuals with sensitivities or allergies to gluten or artificial ingredients.
* Health-conscious bakers who prioritize clean, non-GMO ingredients.
Unique Selling Points
- Completely free of artificial dyes, using only vegetable colored sources for a vibrant look.
- A unique soft texture that is perfect for young children or anyone who dislikes the hard, waxy feel of traditional sprinkles.
- Meets multiple dietary requirements, making them an excellent, inclusive choice for parties and events.
A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles: Key Features & Real-World Performance
After putting these sprinkles to the test, I was able to get a clear picture of how their key features perform in practice. It’s one thing to read a label, but it’s another to see how plant-based dessert toppings hold up to baking, frosting, and freezing. Here’s a deep dive into my findings.
Color Vibrancy: Are Natural Colors as Bright as Artificial Dyes?
My first impression upon opening the resealable container was that the colors were genuinely bright and cheerful. For a dye-free product, this was a pleasant surprise. Often, natural colors can appear muted or earthy, but these rainbow jimmies had a festive pop that rivaled many artificially colored brands. The yellows, oranges, and reds were particularly strong and looked fantastic.
In my topping test on white buttercream frosting, the vibrant colors remained distinct and didn’t fade, even after sitting out for over 24 hours. They don’t possess the synthetic, almost neon gloss of sprinkles made with artificial dyes, but their aesthetic is clean, appealing, and incredibly kid-friendly. The finish is more matte, which I found to be a positive, as it looked more natural and less plasticky on desserts.
Taste & Texture: Do They Have That Weird Artificial Aftertaste?
This is the area where A Great Surprise sprinkles truly excel and set themselves apart. The first thing I noticed is their soft texture. Unlike traditional sprinkles that are hard and waxy, these have a unique quality that causes them to melt in your mouth almost immediately. It’s a pleasant sensation that blends seamlessly with frosting or ice cream rather than adding a distracting, hard crunch.
Most importantly, there is absolutely no weird artificial aftertaste. Many cheap, mass-produced sprinkles have a distinct chemical or waxy flavor that can ruin a perfectly good dessert. These, however, just taste sweet and clean. This makes them a superior choice for decorating delicately flavored desserts where you don’t want the toppings to interfere with the taste. The softer not crunchy texture also makes them a much safer and more enjoyable option for very young children.
Baking Performance: Do Natural Sprinkles Bleed or Melt?
One of the biggest tests for any sprinkle is how it performs when you bake with natural colors. I was specifically looking to see if they would melt into oblivion or bleed their colors into the dough, creating a muddy mess. I used them to make “funfetti” cookies, mixing them directly into the batter.
When baked, the sprinkles held their shape remarkably well. There was some very minimal melting, but they were still clearly visible as distinct sprinkles in the finished cookie. The color bleed was also impressively low, with only slight tinting of the dough immediately surrounding the sprinkle. For a natural sprinkles product, this is an excellent result. When used as a topping on the moist frosting, I observed virtually no color bleed over a 24-hour period, a common failure for many other natural brands. This reliability ensures your decorated desserts stay looking crisp and beautiful for much longer.
Ingredient Quality: What Are Plant-Based Sprinkles Actually Made Of?
A huge selling point for these sprinkles is the clean label and ingredient transparency. The primary ingredients are simple: sugar, cornstarch, vegetable oil, and natural colorants. Being plant-based, they are suitable for strict vegan diets. The brand also ensures they are non-GMO and marketed as gluten-friendly, which caters to a wide range of dietary preferences and needs.
The colors are derived from sources like turmeric (yellow), spirulina (blue/green), and beet juice (red/pink). This is a critical feature for anyone looking to avoid artificial food dyes, which have been linked to various health concerns. This commitment to plant-based ingredients and transparency provides peace of mind, allowing for guilt-free indulgence, especially when serving desserts to children or guests with dietary restrictions.
What Real Users Say: Customer Experiences & Feedback Analysis
Beyond my own real baking experience, I analyzed hundreds of customer feedback entries and A Great Surprise sprinkles user reviews across various online platforms. This helps to form a broader, more objective view and confirms that my findings align with the experiences of other verified buyers. The overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with a few consistent points of discussion.
Users consistently praise these vegan sprinkles for their clean taste and dye-free formula. The most frequently mentioned positives are the lack of a chemical aftertaste and the soft texture, which is a major hit with parents. The main point of polarization, just as in my tests, is the texture—some adore it, while others miss the traditional crunch.
- Taste and Aftertaste: This is the most common praise. Verified buyer opinions are filled with comments that the sprinkles “taste yummy” and are refreshingly free of the “weird artificial aftertaste” that ruins other brands. Many state they will never go back to conventional sprinkles for this reason alone.
- Soft Texture: This attribute is the most debated. A large majority of users, particularly parents, see the softer not crunchy texture as a huge benefit. They describe it as “melt-in-your-mouth” and “perfect for toddlers.” However, a smaller but vocal group expresses disappointment, noting they were expecting a classic, hard crunch and found these too soft for their liking.
- Vibrant, Natural Colors: Consumers are generally very impressed with how bright the plant-based colors are. Many sprinkles testimonials mention that they are a fantastic “healthier alternative” that still provides a fun, colorful appearance for birthday parties and celebrations.
- Kid-Friendly: Parents are a core audience, and their reviews are glowing. They frequently recommend these as a “guilt-free” and “safe” option for children’s desserts due to the allergy-friendly ingredients and lack of artificial dyes.
- Performance: Bakers in the community report positive results, noting that the sprinkles perform reliably in and on baked goods. They confirm my findings of minimal bleeding, which makes them a trusted choice for decorating cakes and cupcakes.
✅ What We Loved: A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles Pros
After weeks of testing, several key advantages stood out that make these sprinkles a top-tier choice. They consistently delivered on their promises and exceeded my expectations in a few key areas, solidifying them as a superior natural sprinkles option.
✅ No Artificial Aftertaste, Just Clean Sweetness
During every single taste test, the flavor was purely sweet and pleasant. There were none of the chemical, waxy, or bitter notes that are so common in other sprinkles, especially bulk ones. This is a massive advantage, as it ensures the flavor of your dessert—whether it’s a vanilla cupcake or a rich chocolate brownie—is the star of the show.
✅ Wonderfully Soft, Melt-in-Your-Mouth Texture
Instead of adding a hard, distracting crunch, these sprinkles dissolve smoothly. This unique soft texture was a standout feature during my testing. It was especially wonderful on softer foods like ice cream and yogurt, where it blended in seamlessly instead of feeling like little bits of plastic. For this reason, I find them superior for many applications.
✅ Vibrant Colors from Natural Ingredients
I was initially skeptical that plant-based ingredients could produce such bright colors, but they do. The A Great Surprise Rainbow Sprinkles look festive, fun, and appealing, solving the common problem of dye-free options appearing dull or brownish. They looked just as celebratory on a birthday cake as their artificially colored counterparts.
✅ Truly Diet-Friendly and Allergen-Conscious
The fact that these sprinkles are vegan, non-GMO, and gluten-friendly makes them an incredibly inclusive and worry-free option for parties, school events, or any gathering. As a host, it removes the guesswork and stress of catering to guests with different dietary needs, which I consider a huge real-world benefit.
✅ Resists Color Bleeding Remarkably Well
This was one of the most impressive discoveries. In my 24-hour frosting test, the colors stayed sharp and distinct with almost zero bleeding. This is a notorious failure point for many natural sprinkles, but A Great Surprise performs exceptionally well here, ensuring your decorated desserts look crisp and clean for hours.
✅ Convenient and Economical Bulk Packaging
The large, resealable container is a fantastic and practical feature for anyone who bakes frequently. It protects the sprinkles from humidity, keeps them fresh, and is easy to store. Buying in bulk offers much better value for money compared to purchasing multiple small, expensive bottles of other natural sprinkle brands.
❌ What Could Be Better: A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles Cons
No product is perfect, and in the spirit of a completely honest review, it’s important to highlight the potential drawbacks. While these A Great Surprise sprinkles are excellent, there are a few limitations to be aware of that might make them the wrong choice for certain people or uses.
❌ Texture Is Soft, Not Crunchy
The most significant “con” is also one of its strengths, depending on your preference. If you are specifically seeking that classic, hard, crunchy texture to add a contrasting element to a soft dessert, these will likely disappoint. Their signature melt-in-your-mouth quality is a clear departure from traditional jimmies.
* Who this affects most: Bakers and dessert lovers who prize a distinct crunchy texture in their sprinkles.
❌ Finish is Matte, Not Glossy
While the colors are vibrant, they have a more natural, matte finish. They lack the high-gloss sheen found on conventional sprinkles, which is often created by a confectioner’s glaze (shellac, an insect byproduct, which is not vegan). This is a minor aesthetic point and not a quality flaw, but it may be noticeable to professional decorators aiming for a specific look.
* Workaround: This is an inherent characteristic of most truly vegan and clean label sprinkles. Embrace the natural, less-plasticky look.
❌ Positioned as a Premium Alternative
These high-quality, dye-free vegan sprinkles come with a higher price tag than the cheap, conventional sprinkles you can grab for a couple of dollars. The cost is justified by the clean, non-GMO ingredients and certifications, but it may not fit into every budget.
* Who this affects most: Very price-conscious consumers or bakers who go through massive quantities of sprinkles and do not prioritize natural or vegan ingredients.
A Great Surprise vs. Alternatives: How Do They Compare?
When evaluating A Great Surprise vs Supernatural Sprinkles and other vegan sprinkles alternatives, its primary differentiators are its uniquely soft texture and excellent value in bulk. While other brands may offer crunchier textures or more elaborate shapes, A Great Surprise masters the classic “jimmie” style with a cleaner taste and softer bite. It successfully bridges the gap between expensive boutique brands and lower-quality grocery store options.
Here’s a quick comparison to help you choose the best natural sprinkles brand for your needs:
Comparison Table
| Feature/Aspect | A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles | Pure Food By Estee Natural Rainbow Sprinkles | 365 by Whole Foods Market, Rainbow Sprinkles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Texture | Soft, melt-in-your-mouth | Traditional Crunch | Traditional Crunch |
| Key Features | Vegan, Dye-Free, Non-GMO, Gluten-Friendly, Bulk Sizes Available | All-Natural Dyes, Vegan, Gluten-Free | Vegan, Classic Rainbow Shapes |
| Best For | Bulk buyers, fans of soft texture, parents of young kids | Those seeking a classic crunch with natural ingredients | Budget-conscious vegan shoppers needing a smaller quantity |
| Price Tier | Mid-Range (great value in bulk) | Premium (in smaller quantity) | Budget-Friendly |
| Our Rating | 4.5/5 ⭐ | 4.0/5 ⭐ | 3.8/5 ⭐ |
A Great Surprise positions itself as the ideal choice for frequent bakers who want clean ingredients without paying the high per-ounce price of boutique brands. It offers the ingredient quality of a premium product but in a more economical, value-oriented format.
Compared to Pure Food By Estee Natural Rainbow Sprinkles, the most significant difference is texture. A Great Surprise is soft, while Pure Food by Estee provides a traditional crunch. Your preference here will be the deciding factor.
Against the 365 by Whole Foods Market, Rainbow Sprinkles, A Great Surprise offers a better value proposition for those who bake often, thanks to its large bulk containers. It also has a slightly softer texture and a stronger emphasis on the “dye-free” promise, which is a key selling point for health-conscious families.
Is A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles Worth the Money? Value Analysis
So, is A Great Surprise worth it? Given that they are positioned at a higher price point than conventional sprinkles, it’s a fair question. After extensive testing and analysis, my answer is a resounding yes—for the right person. The value isn’t just in the product itself, but in the peace of mind it provides.
You are paying for high-quality, plant-based ingredients and the complete absence of artificial dyes. For parents concerned about the potential effects of synthetic colors, for bakers serving a vegan clientele, or for anyone with food sensitivities, this added assurance represents immense value that goes beyond the dollar amount. The dye-free sprinkles price is worth it if clean ingredients are a priority for you.
When you break down the cost on a per-ounce basis, the bulk containers from A Great Surprise often prove to be more economical in the long run than many other “natural” or boutique sprinkle brands that are only sold in small, expensive jars. The initial investment might be higher, but if you’re a frequent baker, you will save money over time.
The long-term value is also excellent. The sturdy, resealable tub keeps the sprinkles fresh for a long time, preventing waste. Ultimately, if your priority is simply finding the cheapest possible colorful decoration for a cake, this isn’t it. But if you’re asking, “should I buy vegan sprinkles that taste great, perform well, and are made with ingredients you can feel good about?”, then A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles deliver exceptional value for their cost.
FAQs: Common Questions About A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles
Here are answers to some of the most common questions people have about these dye-free sprinkles.
Are A Great Surprise sprinkles vegan?
Yes, A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles are 100% vegan. They are made entirely from plant-based ingredients and do not contain common non-vegan additives like confectioner’s glaze (shellac, which comes from insects) or carmine (a red colorant from beetles). This makes them a safe and trusted choice for a strict vegan diet.
Do A Great Surprise sprinkles taste good?
Yes, they taste very good. My testing confirmed what many other users report: they have a clean, simple sweetness with no artificial or chemical aftertaste. Unlike waxy sprinkles that can taste like plastic, these have a pleasant flavor that complements your desserts rather than interfering with them.
Are these sprinkles crunchy or soft?
These sprinkles are distinctly soft. They do not have the hard, crunchy texture of traditional sprinkles. Instead, they have a unique texture that gives way easily and melts in your mouth. This is a key feature that many people love, especially for children, but it’s a drawback if you’re seeking a textural crunch.
Are A Great Surprise sprinkles dye-free?
Yes, they are completely dye-free. This is one of their core selling points. All the colors in the rainbow mix are derived from natural, vegetable colored sources, such as spirulina, turmeric, and beet juice. They provide bright, vibrant color without any synthetic food dyes like Red 40, Yellow 5, or Blue 1.
Are A Great Surprise sprinkles gluten-friendly?
Yes, the product is marketed as “gluten-friendly.” This means the recipe does not include any wheat or gluten-containing ingredients. However, it’s important to note the package warning that they are repackaged in a facility that may handle wheat. For those with general gluten avoidance, they are a great option, but individuals with celiac disease should exercise caution due to the potential for cross-contamination.
How do A Great Surprise sprinkles compare to Supernatural?
A Great Surprise and Supernatural serve different needs in the natural sprinkle market. A Great Surprise is your go-to for classic, soft-textured rainbow jimmies in economical bulk containers. Supernatural is famous for its creative, crunchy sprinkle blends, often featuring various shapes and using natural waxes to achieve that crunch. Choose A Great Surprise for soft texture and bulk value; choose Supernatural for crunchy, designer blends.
Final Verdict: Should You Buy A Great Surprise Vegan Sprinkles? Who It’s Perfect For
After three weeks of comprehensive testing, the verdict is clear: A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles are a fantastic choice for the modern, health-conscious baker. They successfully deliver vibrant colors and a pleasant taste without the artificial ingredients, weird aftertaste, or animal byproducts found in conventional sprinkles. Their unique soft texture and reliable performance make them a standout product.
Perfect for you if…
* ✅ You follow a vegan or plant-based diet and need a 100% compliant dessert topping.
* ✅ You are a parent looking for a dye-free and kid-friendly sprinkle option without sacrificing fun.
* ✅ You despise the waxy, chemical aftertaste of cheap sprinkles and prioritize a clean, sweet flavor.
* ✅ You prefer a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture over a hard, waxy crunch.
* ✅ You bake frequently and want an economical bulk option for clean-label sprinkles.
Not the best choice if…
* ❌ Your top priority is adding a hard, crunchy texture to your desserts.
* ❌ You are on a very tight budget and need the absolute cheapest option available, regardless of ingredients.
* ❌ You are a professional decorator who requires a high-gloss, shellac-based finish for a specific aesthetic.
For those who need a traditional crunch, a conventional brand might be more suitable. But if you fall into the “Perfect For You” category, the A Great Surprise Dye-Free Rainbow Sprinkles earn our enthusiastic recommendation. They are a delicious, vibrant, and guilt-free way to bring joy to your desserts.
Last update on 2026-02-19 at 16:28 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
