Baked Vs. Fried Empanadas: Which Cooking Method Is Better?

Q: Are empanadas fried or baked in Spain?

In Spain, the smaller versions known as empanadillas are traditionally fried, not baked. These are a popular tapa and are often filled with a savory mixture of tuna, tomato, and onion. The larger Spanish empanada gallega is a full-sized pie that is baked.

The great empanada debate often comes down to one crucial question: should they be baked or fried? This single choice dramatically impacts everything from the final texture and flavor to the healthiness of the finished product. You might be wondering which method is more authentic, which is easier for a weeknight dinner, or simply which one tastes better.

Empanadas can be either baked for a lighter, flakier result with less fat, or fried for a richer, crispier, and more indulgent texture. The best method depends on personal preference for texture, health considerations, and the specific regional tradition you wish to follow.

This guide provides a definitive, head-to-head comparison based on culinary science and tradition. We will unpack the pros and cons of each method, explore the rich history behind regional preferences, and provide a versatile recipe that lets you choose your own culinary adventure. By the end, you’ll know exactly how to create your perfect empanada.

Key Facts

Ancient Origins: The empanada’s history dates back to the 1500s in Spain and Portugal, from where Spanish immigrants introduced it to South America and beyond.
A Clear Regional Divide: Baking is the traditional method in South American countries like Argentina and Chile, while frying is the prevalent technique in Colombia, Spain, and the Caribbean islands.
The Healthier Choice: Baked empanadas are demonstrably healthier, containing significantly fewer calories and less fat because the cooking process requires little to no oil.
Texture is a Trade-Off: Frying creates a uniquely crispy and crunchy exterior that baking cannot fully replicate, while baking produces a more delicate, light, and flaky pastry crust.
Temperature is Non-Negotiable: Achieving the perfect empanada requires precise heat management. Data shows the ideal range for baking is 350°F to 400°F, while frying demands a consistent oil temperature of 350°F to prevent sogginess or burning.

☰ Table of Contents ▼ show

Baked vs. Fried Empanadas: A Head-to-Head Comparison

Empanadas can be either baked for a lighter, flakier result with less fat, or fried for a richer, crispier, and more indulgent texture. The best method depends on personal preference for texture and health. Trying to decide which empanada is right for your dinner table? Here’s the ultimate cheat sheet.

Feature	Baked Empanadas	Fried Empanadas
Texture	Light, flaky, soft, and bread-like	Crispy, crunchy, and bubbly
Flavor	Milder, highlights the filling	Rich, savory, and more indulgent
Health Factor	Lower in fat and calories	Higher in fat and calories
Cooking Time	Longer (includes preheating)	Faster (cooks in minutes per batch)
Best For…	Health-conscious meals, large batches, easy cleanup	A decadent treat, authentic street-food style, maximum crunch

The Case for Baked Empanadas: Healthier & Flakier

Baked empanadas are a healthier option, resulting in a light, flaky crust. They are ideal for cooking large batches with easier cleanup, though they take longer to cook and may not be as crispy as fried versions. Baking is the go-to method for those who prioritize health and convenience without sacrificing flavor. By cooking in an oven between 350°F to 400°F, you use significantly less oil, creating a lighter hand pie that lets the filling shine.

Pros of Baked Empanadas:
* Healthier: This is the biggest advantage. With fewer calories and dramatically less fat, baked empanadas are a guilt-free way to enjoy this classic dish.
* Easier Batch Cooking: You can fit many empanadas on a baking sheet and cook them all at once, making it perfect for feeding a crowd or for meal prepping.
* Less Messy: Say goodbye to oil splatters and the lingering smell of a deep fryer. Cleanup is as simple as washing a baking sheet.
* Flaky, Tender Crust: Baking often yields a wonderfully delicate and flaky crust, similar to a savory pie or pastry.

Cons of Baked Empanadas:
* Longer Cooking Time: When you factor in the time it takes for the oven to preheat, the total time from prep to plate is longer than frying.
* Risk of Dryness: If left in the oven for too long, the dough can become dry or tough.
* Less Crispy: While a baked empanada can be golden and firm, it won’t achieve the same level of satisfying crunch as its fried counterpart.

Pro Tip: To avoid dryness and get that perfect golden sheen, don’t forget the egg wash before baking—it’s a game-changer!

The Allure of Fried Empanadas: Crispy & Indulgent

Fried empanadas offer a distinctively crispy, crunchy texture and a rich, indulgent flavor. While higher in fat and messier to prepare, they cook much faster than their baked counterparts. For many, the quintessential empanada experience is defined by the incredible crunch that only frying can deliver. The dough puffs up and becomes bubbly and golden, creating a perfect contrast to the savory filling inside.

Pros of Fried Empanadas:
* Superior Crispy Texture: Frying creates a deeply crunchy, blistered, and satisfying exterior that is simply irresistible.
* Rich, Savory Flavor: The hot oil enhances the flavor of the dough, making the entire empanada taste more decadent and satisfying.
* Faster Cooking Time: Once your oil is hot, each batch of empanadas cooks in just 5-7 minutes, making the actual cooking process very quick.

Cons of Fried Empanadas:
* Higher in Fat and Calories: The dough absorbs oil during the frying process, significantly increasing the fat and calorie content.
* Messier to Prepare: Frying involves hot, splattering oil, which requires more caution and a more intensive cleanup process.
* Requires Careful Temperature Control: This is the most critical factor for success.

Maintaining the correct oil temperature is crucial. The sweet spot is around 350°F. If the oil is too cool, the empanadas will absorb too much and become greasy. If it’s too hot, the outside will burn before the filling is properly heated through.

Quick Fact: Did you know that the crispy texture of a fried empanada comes from the rapid dehydration of the dough’s surface when it hits the hot oil?

Regional Traditions: Is There a “Right” Way?

There is no single “right” way; the cooking method is tied to regional traditions. Empanadas are typically baked in countries like Argentina and Chile, while they are commonly fried in Spain, Colombia, and the Caribbean. The dish originated in Spain and Portugal around the 1500s and was spread across the world by immigrants, with each new culture adapting it to their own tastes and available ingredients. This is why the baked vs. fried debate is so deeply rooted in cultural identity.

So, while you might be debating in your kitchen, entire countries have already picked a side. Which tradition will you follow?

Argentina & Chile: Baking is the more common and traditional method in these South American powerhouses. In many parts of Argentina, like Salta, empanadas are traditionally baked to perfection.
Colombia & Caribbean Islands: Frying is the prevalent technique here, resulting in the crispy, golden pockets often sold by street vendors.
Spain: The country of origin prefers to fry its smaller versions, known as empanadillas, which are often filled with tuna and tomato.
Tucumán, Argentina: Proving there are exceptions to every rule, this Argentinian province famously fries its empanadas, setting it apart from the rest of the country.

Versatile Empanada Recipe: You Choose How to Cook It

This versatile beef and potato empanada recipe works perfectly whether you choose to bake for a flaky finish or fry for a crispy crunch. Follow the core filling steps, then choose your cooking path. The beauty of this recipe is its adaptability, empowering you to make the perfect empanada based on your new expertise.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXFgaowlmWA

For the Filling:
1. Sauté 1 finely chopped onion and 2 cloves of minced garlic in a pan until softened.
2. Add 1 lb of ground beef and cook until browned. Drain any excess fat.
3. Stir in 1 large potato, peeled and finely diced.
4. Season with cumin, paprika, salt, and pepper to taste. Cook for another 5-10 minutes until the potato is tender. Allow the filling to cool completely before assembling.

Assembly:
1. Roll out your empanada dough and cut it into circles (about 5-6 inches in diameter).
2. Place a spoonful of the cooled beef and potato filling onto one side of each dough circle.
3. Fold the other side of the dough over the filling to create a half-moon shape.
4. Press the edges together firmly and crimp with a fork or create a decorative repulgue (braided) seal.

For Baked Empanadas

Preheat your oven to 400°F (204°C).
Place the assembled empanadas on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.
For a golden, shiny finish, brush each empanada with an egg wash (one egg beaten with a splash of milk or water).
Bake for 20-25 minutes, or until the crust is golden brown and firm to the touch.

For Fried Empanadas

Heat about 2-3 inches of neutral oil (like canola or vegetable) in a deep pot or skillet to 350°F (177°C).
Carefully place 2-3 empanadas into the hot oil, being careful not to overcrowd the pan.
Fry for about 2-3 minutes per side, until they are deep golden brown and crispy.
Remove with a slotted spoon and let them drain on a wire rack or paper towels.

Which method will you try first with this recipe? Let us know how your perfect empanadas turn out!

To make the assembly process faster and more uniform, consider using an empanada press, which helps seal and crimp the dough perfectly every time.

FAQs About are empanadas baked or fried

Are Argentinian empanadas baked or fried?

While there are regional exceptions (like Tucumán, where they’re fried), Argentinian empanadas are most commonly and traditionally baked. In many parts of Argentina, like Salta, empanadas are traditionally baked, giving them a softer, pastry-like crust that is a hallmark of the region’s cuisine.

Are empanadas fried or baked in Spain?

In Spain, the smaller versions known as empanadillas are traditionally fried, not baked. These are a popular tapa and are often filled with a savory mixture of tuna, tomato, and onion. The larger Spanish empanada gallega is a full-sized pie that is baked.

Are baked empanadas healthy?

Baked empanadas are considered a healthier option than fried ones because they use little to no oil in the cooking process, resulting in fewer calories and less fat. While the filling and dough still contain calories, choosing to bake is a significant step toward a lighter meal.

Do you use the same dough for baked and fried empanadas?

While many dough recipes are versatile enough for both methods, some cooks prefer a flakier dough like puff pastry for baking and a firmer dough for frying to prevent it from becoming greasy. A sturdier dough holds up better to the hot oil, ensuring a crispy, not soggy, result.

Final Summary: Choosing Between Baked and Fried Empanadas

The decision of whether are empanadas baked or fried is ultimately a personal one, driven by your priorities in the kitchen. There is no universally “better” method, only the method that is better for you right now. Whether you crave the indulgent, crispy satisfaction of a fried empanada or the lighter, flakier, and healthier profile of a baked one, the choice is yours. Both paths lead to a delicious, satisfying meal.

Now that you’re an expert on the great empanada debate, it’s time to head to the kitchen!

Choose BAKING for… a lighter, flakier, healthier hand pie that’s easier to make in large batches with minimal mess.
Choose FRYING for… a supremely crispy, rich, and indulgent experience that delivers that authentic street-food crunch.
Consider TRADITION… if you’re aiming for a specific regional style (e.g., Argentinian vs. Colombian).

Which method will you choose tonight?

Last update on 2025-08-27 at 11:05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API