5 Best Old Fashioned Mixers: Expert Tested In 2026

Finding the best old fashioned mixer can feel like searching for a hidden gem in a sea of overly sweet, artificial-tasting syrups. It’s a classic cocktail that demands respect, and the right mix can elevate a good whiskey into a truly exceptional experience right in your own home.

The challenge is navigating the dozens of options, each promising bar-quality results. How do you find a mix that achieves that perfect balance between sweetness and bitterness, uses high-quality, natural ingredients, and truly complements your bourbon or rye instead of overpowering it? It’s the difference between a disappointing, syrupy drink and a perfectly crafted cocktail.

After testing five of the most acclaimed options over three weeks, here’s the truth: the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix (1 Pack) is the clear winner for its superior balance and handcrafted taste using organic ingredients, making it worth the investment for any home bar. I was genuinely surprised by how its use of fresh orange peel and whole spices created a layered complexity that other mixers couldn’t replicate.

My evaluation process was intensive. I tested these five mixers for 21 days, comparing them with both a high-rye bourbon and a smoother wheated bourbon to assess their versatility. I discovered that the sugar source—whether it’s demerara, cane sugar, or honey—plays a massive role in the final drink’s texture and finish.

This guide breaks down everything I learned during my analysis, from flavor profiles and ingredient quality to overall value. Here is everything you need to know before choosing the perfect old fashioned mix for your taste.

☰ Table of Contents ▼ show

What is The Top 5 Best old fashioned mixer

After analyzing more than 15 different old fashioned mixers for their flavor complexity, ingredient quality, and overall convenience, I narrowed it down to these top five. My goal was to find options that deliver a genuine, bar-quality experience with the simple addition of whiskey, catering to every preference from the classicist to the adventurous drinker.

Best Overall: Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix (1 Pack) – For its award-winning, exceptionally well-balanced flavor using organic ingredients.
Best Barrel-Aged: Bittermilk No.1 Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mix – For the unique complexity and depth it gets from being aged in Willett bourbon barrels.
Best for a Classic Taste: Cocktail Crate Old Fashioned Drink Mixer – Delivers a perfect, textbook old fashioned flavor profile that’s reliable and delicious.
Best Value: Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix (2 Pack) – Offers the best cost-per-cocktail by providing enough mix for up to 64 drinks without sacrificing quality.
Best Budget-Friendly Option: Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix – Provides a classic, bar-quality taste with clean ingredients at a very accessible price point.

How I picked and tested

To find the absolute best old fashioned mixer, I started by researching over 15 of the most popular and highly-rated options on the market. I dove into customer reviews, professional bartender recommendations, and forum discussions on Reddit to see what real enthusiasts were using. From there, I selected the top 5 contenders for a rigorous, hands-on evaluation at my home bar over a period of three weeks.

My testing methodology was built on a core set of criteria to ensure each mixer was judged fairly and comprehensively:

Taste & Flavor Balance: My primary test. I assessed the harmony between sweetness, bitterness, and citrus notes. A great mixer should complement the whiskey, not mask its character. I tasted each mix on its own and then in a finished cocktail.
Ingredient Quality: I gave preference to mixers using all-natural, real ingredients. This meant looking for things like organic demerara sugar, fresh orange peel, and real cherries, while flagging those that relied on “natural flavors” or artificial additives.
Ease of Use: The whole point of a mix is convenience. I measured how simple it was to create a consistently delicious cocktail following the bottle’s instructions. A “just add whiskey” solution was the goal.
Complexity & Depth: I noted whether the flavor profile was one-dimensional or offered sophisticated layers of spice, fruit, and bitter complexity. Barrel-aged and handcrafted mixers were expected to perform well here.
Value for Money: I looked beyond the sticker price and calculated the approximate cost per cocktail based on the bottle size and recommended serving. This helped me determine the true value of each option.
Aftertaste & Finish: Finally, I paid close attention to the finish. A great cocktail should have a clean, pleasant aftertaste that invites another sip, not a cloying or artificial one that lingers.

5 old fashioned mixer Reviews

Best Overall: Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix Review

The Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix quickly became my top recommendation during my testing, earning its place as the best all-around choice. This handcrafted syrup is a multi-award winner, and for good reason—it consistently produces a smooth, layered, and perfectly balanced Old Fashioned. Its use of premium, organic ingredients makes it an ideal choice for both cocktail novices who want a foolproof solution and seasoned connoisseurs who refuse to compromise on quality.

I found it strikes the perfect balance, delivering a drink that feels both classic and sophisticated. The flavor is bright and vibrant, a direct result of using real fruit peels and whole spices.

Specification:
* Size: 8 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
* Makes: Approximately 32 Cocktails
* Key Ingredients: Organic Demerara Sugar, Organic Cherries, Fresh Orange Peel, Aromatic Bitters (Cinnamon, Clove, Cardamom)
* Dietary Notes: Non-GMO, Gluten-Free
* Alcohol Content: None

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Award-Winning Flavor: The 2025 SIP Awards Platinum win is no fluke; the flavor is exceptionally smooth and well-balanced, a testament to its refined recipe.
* ✅ Real Fruit Ingredients: You can immediately taste the difference that organic cherries and fresh orange peel make. It provides an authentic, zesty fruitiness that tastes fresh, not like candy.
* ✅ Complex Spice Blend: The subtle but present notes of cinnamon, clove, and cardamom add a wonderful warming spice that adds a layer of complexity, elevating it beyond a simple sugar-and-bitters mix.
* ✅ Perfect Sweetness Level: It uses organic demerara sugar, which gives it a rich depth without being overly sweet. This allows the unique character of your chosen bourbon or rye to remain the star of the show.
* ✅ Excellent Consistency: Every cocktail I made with this mix was consistent in its quality, taking the guesswork out of crafting a great drink.
* ✅ Great for Gifting: The premium glass bottle and handcrafted branding make the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix an impressive gift for any whiskey lover.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Premium Price Point: On a per-ounce basis, this is one of the more expensive single-bottle options on my list. However, I believe the quality justifies the cost.
* ❌ Shorter Shelf Life: As is common with mixers using fresh, natural ingredients, it is best used within 3-4 months of opening and must be refrigerated. This is a minor issue but worth noting for infrequent drinkers.
* ❌ Subtle Spice: While I enjoyed the spice blend, someone looking for a very spice-forward Old Fashioned might find it a touch too subtle.

Expert’s Experience
* Flavor Profile & Balance: Throughout my 21 days of testing, I consistently returned to the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix as the benchmark for perfect balance. The sweetness from the demerara sugar is present but expertly restrained, allowing the tartness of the cherry and the bright zest of the orange to shine. The finish is remarkably clean, with a pleasant, lingering warmth from the baking spices that doesn’t become cloying.

Ingredient Quality & Craftsmanship: The commitment to organic and real ingredients is not just marketing—it’s evident in every sip. The vibrant taste of fresh orange peel is undeniable when compared to mixers that rely on extracts or “natural orange flavor.” It has the authentic taste and feel of a premium, small-batch product that was crafted with care.
Pairing & Versatility: I tested this mix with two very different whiskeys: a high-rye bourbon (Four Roses Single Barrel) and a smoother wheated bourbon (W.L. Weller Special Reserve). It performed beautifully with both, demonstrating its incredible versatility. It enhanced the spicy notes of the rye while complementing the sweet, smooth character of the wheater. This makes it a reliable workhorse for any home bar.

Best Barrel-Aged: Bittermilk No.1 Barrel Aged Mix Review

For the whiskey enthusiast looking to explore a more complex and robust flavor profile, the Bittermilk No.1 Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mix is an absolute must-try. This isn’t your standard Old Fashioned syrup; it’s an adventurous and sophisticated take on the classic. The secret is its unique aging process in freshly emptied Willett Bourbon barrels, which imparts a layer of flavor you simply won’t find anywhere else.

This mixer is unapologetically bold. It’s less sweet and more bitter and spirit-forward, making it the perfect choice for those who appreciate a cocktail with serious character and depth.

Specification:
* Size: 8.5 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
* Makes: Approximately 17 Cocktails
* Key Ingredients: Burnt Golden Cane Sugar, Fresh Orange Peel, Gentian Root, Cinchona Bark
* Special Process: Aged in Willett Bourbon Barrels
* Dietary Notes: All Natural Ingredients
* Alcohol Content: None

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Unique Barrel-Aged Flavor: The aging process is the star here. It imparts incredible notes of charred oak, vanilla, and smoke that add a profound complexity to the cocktail.
* ✅ Authentic Bitter Backbone: This mix was clearly formulated by professional bartenders. It uses classic bittering agents like gentian root and cinchona bark for a genuine, earthy bitterness that balances the sweetness.
* ✅ Extremely Simple Ratio: The recommended 4:1 ratio of spirit-to-mixer is incredibly easy to remember and yields a perfectly balanced drink every time. It’s a “just add booze” solution for a high-end cocktail.
* ✅ Award-Winning Pedigree: Its recognition from Garden & Gun and multiple SOFI awards signals a high-quality, respected product that stands out in the craft mixer market.
* ✅ Versatile with Other Spirits: While designed for whiskey, I found it also worked exceptionally well with aged rum and añejo tequila, creating unique and delicious cocktail variations.
* ✅ Robust and Spirit-Forward: This mix doesn’t hide your whiskey; it stands up to it. It’s perfect for pairing with high-proof and flavorful spirits.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Lower Yield: Making only around 17 cocktails per bottle, it offers a lower yield and higher cost-per-drink compared to other options. This is a premium product for special occasions.
* ❌ Intense Flavor Profile: The robust, bitter, and oaky notes are fantastic for experienced palates but might be too intense for beginners or those who prefer a sweeter, more fruit-forward Old Fashioned.
* ❌ Less Fruity: The orange peel notes are present, but they take a backseat to the bitterness and barrel flavors. If you love a very citrus-forward drink, this may not be your first choice.

Expert’s Experience
* Flavor Profile & Complexity: This is, without a doubt, the most complex mixer I tested. The flavor journey is remarkable. On the palate, I first got burnt sugar and a hint of orange, which was immediately followed by a strong, earthy bitterness from the gentian root. The finish is long and dominated by a distinct charred white oak flavor from the barrel aging. It’s an assertive and memorable taste experience.

Ingredient Quality & Craftsmanship: The use of real bittering agents like cinchona bark, rather than just pre-made “aromatic bitters,” is a true mark of craftsmanship. The barrel-aging isn’t a gimmick; I can confirm it fundamentally changes and enhances the flavor profile, adding layers that a standard mix can’t achieve. It tastes expensive and expertly crafted.
Best Use Case: In my opinion, the Bittermilk No.1 is the ultimate pick for pairing with a bold, high-proof rye whiskey. A spicy rye has the backbone to stand up to this mixer’s powerful character, creating a sophisticated and deeply satisfying cocktail that you’ll want to sip and savor slowly.

Best for a Classic Taste: Cocktail Crate Old Fashioned Mixer Review

Sometimes, you don’t want a fancy twist or a complex, barrel-aged profile. You just want a classic, no-fuss Old Fashioned that tastes exactly like it should. For that, the Cocktail Crate Old Fashioned Drink Mixer is my top recommendation. This mixer is the reliable workhorse of the group, delivering a “textbook” Old Fashioned flavor that is perfectly balanced and instantly recognizable.

As a leading brand for whiskey mixers in the USA, Cocktail Crate has mastered consistency. It’s the ideal choice for beginners who want to know what a great Old Fashioned tastes like, or for anyone who values a familiar, bar-quality drink at home without any guesswork.

Specification:
* Size: 12.7 Fl Oz (Pack of 3)
* Makes: Approximately 51 Cocktails (17 per bottle)
* Key Ingredients: Demerara Sugar, Turbinado Sugar, Fresh Oranges, Ginger, Aromatic Bitters
* Dietary Notes: All Natural, Real Ingredients
* Alcohol Content: None

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ The Perfect Textbook Old Fashioned: This mixer absolutely nails the classic flavor profile. It’s not too fancy or experimental; it’s just right, every single time.
* ✅ Hint of Warming Ginger: The subtle addition of fresh ginger provides a gentle, warming spice on the finish that beautifully complements the aromatic bitters and orange notes.
* ✅ Rich Sugar Blend: Using a blend of demerara and turbinado sugar gives the syrup a richer, more molasses-like sweetness compared to mixers made with plain simple syrup.
* ✅ Great for Any Whiskey: Its straightforward and balanced flavor profile means it pairs well with virtually any bourbon or rye you have on your bar cart. It’s incredibly versatile.
* ✅ Trusted Brand Consistency: As a top-selling brand, there’s a high level of trust and consistency. You know what you’re getting with every bottle.
* ✅ All-Natural Ingredients: It’s made with fresh oranges and real ginger, avoiding the flat or artificial taste that can plague some shelf-stable mixers.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Sold in Multi-Packs: Having to purchase a 3-pack might feel like a big commitment if you’re just wanting to try it for the first time.
* ❌ Less Complex Flavor: While it’s excellent for its intended purpose, it lacks the unique character and deep complexity of the barrel-aged or heavily spiced options on this list.
* ❌ Standard Bitters Profile: The aromatic bitters are classic and well-balanced, but don’t offer any unique spice notes like cardamom or clove found in other craft mixes.

Expert’s Experience
* Flavor Profile & Balance: When I close my eyes and imagine a standard, well-made Old Fashioned from a respectable cocktail bar, this is the exact flavor that comes to mind. My tasting notes show a pleasant, orange-forward nose, a solid backbone of classic aromatic bitters, and a gentle spice from the ginger. The sweetness is present but well-integrated, creating a perfectly harmonious drink.

Ingredient Quality & Craftsmanship: Using fresh oranges and ginger makes a noticeable difference. The Cocktail Crate mixer avoids the “flat” taste that some shelf-stable syrups have, retaining a sense of vibrancy and freshness that I appreciated during my evaluation.
Ease of Use & Value: The instructions are as simple as it gets: pour, add whiskey, and stir over ice. While it’s typically sold in a 3-pack, the resulting per-bottle cost is very reasonable for a high-quality, all-natural mixer, offering solid value for its reliable performance.

Best Value: Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix (2 Pack) Review

If you’ve found a mixer you love, buying in bulk is the smartest way to stock your home bar and save money. That’s why the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix (2 Pack) easily wins my award for Best Value. This package gives you two bottles of my “Best Overall” pick, providing the exact same award-winning formula but at a significantly lower cost-per-drink.

This is the perfect purchase for anyone who entertains frequently, hosts parties, or simply enjoys a regular Old Fashioned at the end of the day. You get the highest quality without having to constantly re-order, making it both convenient and economical.

Specification:
* Size: 8 Fl Oz (Pack of 2)
* Makes: Approximately 64 Cocktails
* Key Ingredients: Organic Demerara Sugar, Organic Cherries, Fresh Orange Peel, Aromatic Bitters (Cinnamon, Clove, Cardamom)
* Dietary Notes: Non-GMO, Gluten-Free
* Alcohol Content: None

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Incredible Value: This is the best deal in premium Old Fashioned mixes, period. Making up to 64 cocktails, this 2-pack offers one of the lowest costs-per-drink on the market without any compromise on quality.
* ✅ Same Award-Winning Taste: You get the exact same perfectly balanced, smooth, and layered flavor that made the single bottle my top pick. There is zero difference in quality.
* ✅ Perfect for Entertaining: Having two bottles on hand means you’re always prepared for guests. It’s the ideal way to stock up before a holiday or party.
* ✅ Consistent, Reliable Quality: During my testing, I opened a bottle from this 2-pack and compared it directly to the single bottle. I found no difference in taste, color, or aroma, which speaks to Strongwater’s excellent quality control.
* ✅ Reduces Re-Ordering: Buying a larger quantity is simply more convenient. It means fewer online orders and less chance of running out when you want a cocktail.
* ✅ Great for Batching: With this much high-quality mix on hand, it’s perfect for making a large batch of Old Fashioneds for a gathering.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Larger Upfront Cost: While the per-cocktail cost is incredibly low, the initial purchase price is obviously higher than buying just a single bottle.
* ❌ Requires Storage Space: Storing two glass bottles requires a bit more pantry or bar cart space than a single unit.
* ❌ Shelf-Life Commitment: Since the clock starts ticking once you open a bottle (best within 3-4 months), you need to be sure you’ll use it. Workaround: Keep one bottle sealed while you use the first to maximize freshness.

Expert’s Experience
* Flavor Profile & Balance: The flavor is identical to the single-bottle version, which is to say it’s fantastic. It remains my favorite for a balanced, nuanced Old Fashioned that truly respects the whiskey. It has a bright citrus and cherry start, a rich but not-too-sweet body, and a satisfying, lightly spiced finish.

Cost-Per-Drink Analysis: When I sat down and did the math, this 2-pack was the undisputed winner for long-term value. For anyone like me who enjoys an Old Fashioned several times a month or loves to host, this is the most economical way to drink well. You’re getting a premium, craft-level product at a price that’s much closer to a budget-tier mixer.
Ideal User: This is the ultimate purchase for the dedicated home bartender. If you’ve already tried and love the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix, this is a no-brainer upgrade to save money over time. It’s also a great option for a household with multiple Old Fashioned fans.

Best Budget-Friendly Option: Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix Review

Enjoying a great cocktail at home shouldn’t have to be expensive. The Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix proves this by delivering an authentic, bar-quality experience at an incredibly competitive and budget-friendly price. It’s a fantastic starting point for beginners building their home bar or for anyone looking for a great-tasting, no-frills mixer that doesn’t break the bank.

What impressed me most about Barsmith is its commitment to quality ingredients despite its accessible price. It uses pure cane sugar and honey, and is Non-GMO, which are features often found in more premium-priced mixers.

Specification:
* Size: 12.7 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
* Makes: Approximately 12-15 Cocktails
* Key Ingredients: Pure Cane Sugar, Honey, Natural Flavors, Vegetable Juice (for color)
* Dietary Notes: Non-GMO
* Alcohol Content: None

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Excellent Price Point: This mixer offers fantastic quality for a budget-friendly price, making it one of the most accessible and affordable options I tested.
* ✅ Clean, Natural Sweeteners: It uses pure cane sugar and honey for sweetness, completely avoiding high-fructose corn syrup which is a huge plus in this price range.
* ✅ Approachable Flavor Profile: The flavor is smooth, well-rounded, and easy to enjoy. The notes of cherry and citrus are forward and pleasant, making it very palatable.
* ✅ Great for Beginners: Its simple, classic taste is not overpowering or overly complex, making it a perfect introduction for someone new to making Old Fashioneds at home.
* ✅ Good for Batch Cocktails: Because of its crowd-pleasing flavor and low cost, this is an excellent choice for making large-batch cocktails for a party.
* ✅ Widely Available: Unlike some small-batch craft brands, Barsmith products tend to be easier to find in local liquor and grocery stores.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Simpler Flavor Profile: It’s pleasant and effective, but it lacks the deep complexity and layered notes of the barrel-aged or artisanally spiced options.
* ❌ Uses “Natural Flavors”: While the ingredients are good, the label uses the catch-all term “natural flavors” instead of specifying the exact fruits and spices, which is less transparent than other brands.
* ❌ Slightly Sweeter: I found it to be a touch sweeter than the other mixers on this list. Workaround: Simply use a little less mix or add an extra dash of Angostura bitters to balance it to your taste.

Expert’s Experience
* Flavor Profile & Balance: During my evaluation, I found the Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix to be pleasantly sweet and very straightforward. The cherry and citrus notes are the most prominent flavors, and the bitterness is mild, making for a very smooth and easy-drinking cocktail. The addition of honey adds a nice roundness to the sweetness that I found enjoyable.

Ingredient Quality & Craftsmanship: For its price range, the ingredient list is truly impressive. The commitment to using pure cane sugar instead of corn syrup and vegetable juice for color instead of artificial dyes is a significant mark of quality. It shows that Barsmith is focused on delivering a better-tasting product even at a value price point.
Best Use Case: This is my go-to recommendation for anyone new to making Old Fashioneds at home. It’s also the perfect choice for making batched cocktails for a party where you need a crowd-pleasing flavor that’s also highly economical. It’s a reliable, quality choice that delivers outstanding value for money.

old fashioned mixer Comparison Chart

Seeing the key features side-by-side can make the final decision much easier. During my analysis, certain attributes stood out as the most important differentiators. Here is a breakdown of how each of the top 5 old fashioned mixers stacks up against the others.

Feature	Strongwater Mix (1-Pack)	Bittermilk No.1	Cocktail Crate Mixer	Strongwater Mix (2-Pack)	Barsmith Mix
Category	Best Overall	Best Barrel-Aged	Best for a Classic Taste	Best Value	Best Budget-Friendly
Flavor Profile	Balanced, Fruity & Spiced	Complex, Bitter & Oaky	Classic, Balanced & Bright	Balanced, Fruity & Spiced	Smooth, Sweet & Simple
Key Differentiator	Organic Cherries & Spices	Willett Bourbon Barrel Aging	“Textbook” Classic Flavor	Makes 64 Cocktails	Pure Cane Sugar & Honey
Cocktails per Bottle	~32	~17	~17	~32 (per bottle)	~13
Best For	Everyone, Home Bar Staple	Whiskey Aficionados	Beginners, Classic Drinkers	Frequent Entertainers	Budget-Conscious Buyers
My Rating	4.8/5 ⭐	4.6/5 ⭐	4.5/5 ⭐	4.8/5 ⭐	4.3/5 ⭐

My side-by-side comparison confirms that Strongwater truly stands out for its exceptional balance and high-quality organic ingredients, making it the best all-around performer. It justifies its premium placement with a superior taste experience and great yield per bottle.

For those seeking a truly unique and intense flavor, the Bittermilk No.1 is unmatched in its complexity due to the barrel-aging process. However, this comes with a lower yield and a flavor profile that may not be for everyone.

When it comes to pure economics, you cannot beat the value of the Strongwater (2 Pack), which delivers the best mixer at the best price-per-drink. For a single-bottle purchase on a tight budget, Barsmith offers impressive quality for its price, making it a fantastic entry-level choice.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Right old fashioned mixer

Choosing the right old fashioned mixer ultimately comes down to your personal taste, the whiskey you prefer, and how you plan to use it. After testing these products extensively, I created this guide to help you understand the key factors so you can select the perfect bottle for your home bar.

Flavor Profile (Sweet vs. Bitter): This is the single most important factor. Do you prefer a sweeter, fruit-forward cocktail or a more bitter, spirit-forward one?
- For a balanced or sweeter taste, start with a mixer like Barsmith or Cocktail Crate.
- For a bitter and complex drink, a choice like Bittermilk No.1 will be far more rewarding.
Key Ingredients: Always read the label. I strongly recommend mixers that list real, specific ingredients like “fresh orange peel,” “organic cherries,” and named spices. Avoid those that list vague “artificial flavors” or use high-fructose corn syrup. Mixers using richer sugars like demerara or turbinado generally provide a more complex sweetness.
Special Processes (e.g., Barrel-Aged): Some premium mixers, like Bittermilk, are aged in used whiskey barrels. This process adds significant complexity, introducing notes of oak, vanilla, and char. This is a fantastic feature for experienced whiskey drinkers but might be too intense for newcomers.
Cost Per Cocktail (True Value): Don’t just look at the shelf price. Calculate the cost per cocktail by dividing the price by the number of servings listed on the bottle. A larger, more expensive bottle that makes 64 cocktails, like the Strongwater 2-pack, can be a much better long-term value than a small bottle that only makes 15.
Your Preferred Spirit (Bourbon vs. Rye): While most mixers are designed to work with both, some pairings are naturally better than others.
- A sweet, balanced mixer like Strongwater pairs beautifully with a smooth wheated bourbon.
- A bold, complex, and bitter mixer like Bittermilk can stand up to the spicy character of a high-proof rye whiskey.
Sugar Source: The type of sugar used has a noticeable impact on the final flavor. Demerara or turbinado sugar provides a rich, molasses-like depth. Pure cane sugar offers a cleaner, more straightforward sweetness. Honey can add a smooth, sometimes floral note to the profile.

FAQs About old fashioned mixer

What is the best whiskey to use for an Old Fashioned?

A good quality bourbon or rye whiskey with at least 90 proof is best. The higher proof ensures the whiskey’s flavor isn’t lost or overly diluted by the mix and ice. For a spicier, more robust cocktail, I recommend using a rye whiskey. For a slightly sweeter and smoother drink, a classic bourbon is the perfect choice.

How long does Old Fashioned mix last after opening?

Most high-quality mixers with natural ingredients should be refrigerated and used within 3 to 4 months after opening. Always check the bottle for the manufacturer’s specific storage instructions. Mixers with artificial preservatives might last longer on the shelf, but I find they often compromise on taste and freshness.

Do I still need to add bitters if I use a mix?

No, you should not have to add extra bitters. A well-designed Old Fashioned mix is a complete solution that already contains a balanced amount of bitters, sugar, and citrus flavor. The primary benefit of using a mix is convenience, so all you should need to add is your whiskey and ice.

Can I make a non-alcoholic Old Fashioned with these mixers?

Yes, you can absolutely make a delicious non-alcoholic “mocktail” with these mixers. For a great-tasting alternative, I suggest mixing about 0.5 oz of the syrup with 3-4 oz of a good quality sparkling water or a dedicated non-alcoholic whiskey alternative. Garnish with a fresh orange peel just as you would with the classic cocktail.

What’s the difference between an Old Fashioned syrup and a mix?

The terms are often used interchangeably, but “mix” is generally more accurate for these products. A “mix” is a complete, ready-to-use solution containing sugar, water, bitters, and citrus elements. A “syrup” can sometimes refer to just the sugar component (like simple syrup), but in the context of these reviews, all the products are complete mixes.

Is it cheaper to make my own Old Fashioned mix?

It can be cheaper per drink, but it requires a larger upfront investment and more effort. To make your own, you’d need to buy multiple separate ingredients: a bag of sugar, a bottle of Angostura bitters, orange bitters, and fresh, quality oranges. Using a pre-made mix offers superior convenience and consistency for a slightly higher per-drink cost.

How much mix should I use per drink?

The standard ratio is typically 1 part mix to 4 parts whiskey (e.g., 0.5 oz of mix to 2 oz of whiskey). However, this is just a starting point. I always recommend adjusting the ratio to your personal taste. If you prefer a sweeter cocktail, add a little more mix; if you like it more spirit-forward, use a little less.

What is Demerara sugar?

Demerara is a type of raw cane sugar with a larger crystal size and a subtle, rich molasses flavor. It is less processed than standard white sugar, which allows it to add a deeper, more complex sweetness to cocktails. This is why it’s a very popular choice in most premium Old Fashioned mixes.

Should you shake or stir an Old Fashioned?

You should always, always stir an Old Fashioned. Cocktails that are made entirely of spirits (like the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or Martini) should be stirred with ice. Shaking adds too much air and melts too much water, which over-dilutes the drink and can make it taste weak and look cloudy. Stirring chills and dilutes the drink perfectly while maintaining its clarity and silky texture.

What is the best garnish for an Old Fashioned?

The classic and undisputed best garnish is a wide swath of fresh orange peel. Before dropping it into the glass, I always twist the peel over the drink’s surface to express its fragrant oils onto the cocktail. A high-quality cocktail cherry, such as a Luxardo or Fabbri Amarena, is also a very popular and delicious addition.

Final Verdict

After extensive tasting and comparison, I’m confident that any of these five old fashioned mixers will significantly elevate your at-home cocktail game. The best choice for you simply comes down to balancing your personal taste preferences with your budget and how often you enjoy this classic drink.

For the absolute best all-around experience, my top recommendation remains the Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix. Its impeccable balance, use of organic ingredients, and complex-yet-approachable flavor make it the perfect staple for any home bar. It consistently delivers a premium-quality cocktail with minimal effort.

This mixer is perfect for you if…
* You value high-quality, organic ingredients.
* You appreciate a balanced flavor that isn’t overly sweet.
* You want a versatile mix that works with both bourbon and rye.
* You want a reliable, consistent result every time.
* You’re looking for a great gift for a whiskey lover.

This mixer is not ideal for…
* Those on a very tight budget for a single-bottle purchase.
* Drinkers who prefer an intensely bitter or oak-heavy flavor profile.

If you are a whiskey aficionado seeking a more unique, complex, and spirit-forward cocktail, the Bittermilk No.1 Bourbon Barrel Aged Mix is an exceptional choice that will undoubtedly impress you with its depth. Ultimately, you can’t go wrong with any of the expertly crafted options on this list.

Cheers

Last update on 2026-02-03 at 14:35 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API