How to clean bakeware cookie sheets: The 5 Ultimate Guide

In order to find the best way for cleaning discoloured sheet pans, cookie pans, baking pans we checked out five typical approaches for How to clean bakeware cookie sheets.

As an Amazon Associate earns from qualifying purchases.

Do you want to know how to clean bakeware cookie sheets? Cooks use a baking sheet (or sheet pan), and it always has the patina to prove this. There isn’t any baking sheet in the world that isn’t covered in brown patches. A worn, blackened colouration appears on the pan overnight. I refer to it as “well-seasoned,” and these marks are a badge of pride — but at some point, thorough cleaning of bakeware cookie sheets is required.

To get the job done, you’ll need more than a sponge and soapy water. As a result, I experimented with a total of five different cleaning procedures. I wanted to know how to restore a tarnished metal sheet pan to near-new condition.

What Is the Best Way to Clean a Bakeware Cookie Sheet?

Before cleaning your baking sheets, you’ll need to determine which cleaning procedure is appropriate for your pan. (You may like to read: How to Clean Williams Sonoma Gold Baking Sheet). Consult the following chart to see which procedure is safe to use on your kitchen’s cookie sheets.

Method:Aluminized SteelAluminiumNon-Stick
Aluminum Foil YesNoNo
Baking soda and vinegarYesYesNo
Baking soda and hydrogen peroxide YesNoNo
Water and Baking Soda YesYesYes
Washing Soda and Cream of Tartar YesYesYes
Baking Cookie Sheet Cleaning method

How to Clean Bakeware Cookie Sheets: Six Simple Techniques

In this section, you’ll learn how to use the approaches that work best for each pan type.

clean bakeware cookie sheets

1. How to Clean Cookie Sheets with Baking Soda and Peroxide

When using this approach, the most critical consideration is how much time it takes. Baking soda and hydrogen peroxide are all that is needed to clean your pan, but you must allow it to work for a long enough period of time.

  1. Make a paste by combining baking soda and hydrogen peroxide.
  2. Spread the mixture over the pan’s surface.
  3. Allow it to rest for at least two to three hours.
  4. A paper towel and some water can be used to remove the mixture off the surface.
  5. If required, use a scrub brush to remove any leftover dirt.
  6. To remove any leftover residue, use soap and water to wash the sheet.

2. How to Clean Cookie Sheets with Baking Soda and Vinegar

  1. We propose using 1/4 cup of vinegar and 1 part baking soda.
  2. Spread the baking soda evenly on the tray.
  3. You’ll see a chemical reaction taking place as soon as the vinegar is added to the mixture.
  4. Pour some hot water into a sink, and then submerge the tray.
  5. The sheet should be soaked for at least 30 to 60 minutes before use.
  6. Scrub with a scouring pad or steel wool to remove dirt and grime.
  7. Regular soap and water can be used to wash the sheets.

3. How to Clean Cookie Sheets with Ammonia

For difficult stains and food particles, you may use ammonia, but this approach takes the longest to finish and uses harsh chemicals, so you must be careful while applying it. Always use protective gloves and eye protection when handling hazardous materials.

  1. Cookie sheets should be wrapped in a sturdy plastic bag, such as a trash bag, before baking.
  2. In the bag, add 1/2 cup of ammonia.
  3. Allow ample time for the ammonia to soften and react with oil and food particles by sealing the bag and leaving it out in the sun for a day.
  4. Open the bag and remove the pans without breathing in the ammonia.
  5. Steel wool should be used to clean the pans.
  6. Do a thorough cleaning of the sheets.

4. How to Clean Cookie Sheets using Aluminum Foil

  1. For a long amount of time, soak the sheet pans in water..
  2. Remove and allow to air dry.
  3. Fold aluminum foil into a ball and use it to clean burnt patches and stuck-on food.
  4. Rinse with soap and water after washing.

5. How to Clean Cookie Sheets with Washing Soda and Cream of Tartar

  1. Add a layer of cream of tartar and washing soda to the cookie sheet.
  2. Add a tiny quantity of boiling water to the sheet.
  3. Make a paste out of the components by combining them.
  4. Spread the paste across the entire pan.
  5. Wait for 15 minutes before attempting to remove it.
  6. A non-abrasive scrubbing pad can be used to remove stains off surfaces.
  7. Use soap and water to clean the pan of any paste or dirt.

6. How to Clean Cookie Sheets with Baking Soda and Water

  1. Create a paste by mixing baking soda with warm water.
  2. Apply the paste to the cookie sheet.
  3. Allow for a 30-minute resting period.
  4. With a nylon scrubber, gently remove the stains.
  5. Dry your hands as soon as possible after washing.

How to Clean Cookie Sheets with Baked-On Grease

Baked-on oil can be a difficult issue to deal with, but the following procedures for each type of sheet pan will assist to fix the problem.

Aluminum Steel Cookie Sheets:

A few drops of dish detergent and a few drops of water should be added to your aluminum steel cookie sheet before placing it on the burner. Bring the water to a low boil and keep it there for about five minutes. Allow the liquid to cool fully before washing the pan well with a stainless steel scouring pad to remove any baked-on oil.

Bake your aluminum cookie sheets:

Sprinkle them with cream of tartar. Using a burner, bring water to a boil for 5 minutes. Grease should be able to come off using this method. All that’s left is to run water over the area and pat it dry. All that’s left is to run water over the area and pat it dry.

Non-Stick Cookie Sheets:

Make sure the baking soda is evenly distributed on the cookie sheet’s surface before baking. Start the fizzing process by adding vinegar to the baking soda. Allow the sheet to sit for 30 minutes before moving on. It is best to use an old toothbrush to gently remove any leftover oil. Afterward, dry thoroughly.

How to Clean Rust from Cookie Sheets:

Instead of buying new baking pans, use these methods to remove rust and restore your pans to their original condition.

With a Potato and Baking Soda or Dish Soap:

  1. Slice the potato in half.
  2. Dip it in dish soap or baking soda. Experiment with both to see which is better.
  3. Rub the rusty area with a potato. Natural oxalic acid in potatoes will break down rust.
  4. If the potato becomes slippery, chop off the end and re-dip it in the dish soap or baking soda.
  5. Steps should be repeated until all rust has been eliminated.
  6. Rinse and dry the pan as soon as possible.

With Baking Soda:

  • Thoroughly rinse the sheet, then shake it dry so that it is slightly moist.
  • To ensure that the baking soda adheres to the remaining water, lightly coat the pan with the powder.
  • To prevent rust, apply baking soda to any rust patches.
  • Take a break for around 30 minutes.
  • Gently scrape the pan while the baking soda is still in place.
  • Rinse everything well and pat dry with a towel.

How to Clean Cookie Sheets Without Harming

When cleaning your kitchen’s cookie sheet, keep the following in mind.

How to Clean Aluminized Steel Cookie Sheets

An aluminized steel surface is resistant to abrasion and scouring. We recommend using a scouring pad, the rough side of a sponge, or steel wool for whichever technique you choose. Steel wool is great at removing stains, but it may leave microscopic scratch marks on your cookware if you use it incorrectly.

How to Clean Aluminum Cookie Sheets

Like aluminized steel pans and stainless steel pans, aluminum baking sheets can be cleaned with the same procedures. It’s possible that you’ll need a more delicate scrubber. Try a tiny area of the back of the sheet with the scrubber to be sure.

How to Clean Non-Stick Cookie Sheets

Rough or steel scrubbers might damage the nonstick coating on your cookie sheet, so avoid using them. Instead, use nylon scrubbers that won’t scratch surfaces. You should also try covering the cookie sheet with damp paper towels and letting the sheet soak for an hour before moving on to the next step. There’s a chance this will work for a little amount of buildup.

What You Need To Know About Cleaning Bakeware Cookie Sheets

Cleaning and maintaining your cookie sheets may help avoid the buildup of food residue, oil, or corrosion.

  • By using aluminum foil or parchment paper to line your baking sheet, you can save a lot of mess.
  • To keep your pan from rusting, coat it with a thin layer of vegetable oil.
  • After cleaning, make sure to dry the cookie sheets to prevent bacteria growth and rust.
  • After using your cookie sheets, wash them by hand as soon as possible.

When to Replace Your Baking Sheet

Baking sheets may last a long time if you take good care of them, but there are a few warning signs that signal when it’s time to get a new one. You should replace your pan if it is deformed and does not rest flat on the counter. Nonstick baking sheets with peeling coatings should be replaced as soon as possible since you don’t want any of the coating to end up in your meal.

Share your love

Fuad Naser Bondhon is a Leather Engineer and he loves to cook. He's crazy about football and has a wide knowledge of review writing and research. Fuad is an expert in baking, so he researches bakeware sets on the site