Muffin Pan vs Cupcake Pan: Right Choice For Your Baking Needs

Muffin pan vs cupcake pan: Unraveling the sweet mystery! Discover how muffin pans and cupcake pans are exactly the same. Explore their differences in batter capacity and shape, with cupcakes being sweeter and more delicate, while muffin pans hold about 1/3 more batter. Find the perfect pan for your baking delights

As an Amazon Associate earns from qualifying purchases.

Ever wondered about the differences and similarities between “Muffin Pan vs Cupcake Pan“?

We all know the struggle of trying to decide which pan to use for our baking needs, especially when it comes to muffins and cupcakes. The confusion can be real, and it’s a common problem faced by many home bakers and professionals alike.

The answer lies in understanding that while muffin pans and cupcake pans may appear similar, they have distinct features and uses that set them apart.

With years of experience in the baking industry and a deep passion for sharing knowledge, I am here to guide you through this topic. In this article, you’ll learn the key differences between muffin and cupcake pans, their respective uses, and tips on how to choose the right pan for your baking endeavors.

Key Facts:

  • Muffin pans have larger, deeper cavities compared to cupcake pans. (Source: Team Research)
  • Cupcake pans are designed for baking smaller, more delicate cupcakes. (Source: Team Research)
  • Muffin batter tends to be denser than cupcake batter. (Source: Team Research)
  • Cupcake liners can be used in muffin pans. (Source: Team Research)
  • Muffin pans come in different cavity shapes while cupcake pans are typically standard. (Source: Team Research)

Muffin Pan Vs Cupcake Pan: Comparing Difference

Muffin pans and cupcake pans are essentially the same, but there are a few key differences.

  • Muffin pans have deeper sides than cupcake pans. This allows the muffins to rise higher and have a more domed shape.
  • Muffin pans are typically made of metal, while cupcake pans can be made of metal or silicone. Metal muffin pans conduct heat more evenly, which results in more evenly baked muffins.
  • Muffin pans often do not require liners, while cupcake pans typically do. This is because muffin batter is thicker than cupcake batter, and it is less likely to stick to the pan.

So, which pan should you use?

If you are making muffins, a muffin pan is the best option. The deeper sides will help the muffins rise higher and have a more domed shape. If you are making cupcakes, you can use either a muffin pan or a cupcake pan. However, if you want your cupcakes to have a more uniform shape, you may want to use a cupcake pan with liners.

Muffin Pan Vs Cupcake Pan
muffin pan vs cupcake pan

To choose the right pan, you first need to understand the key differences between muffin pans and cupcake pans. Let’s compare their size, shape, capacity, and other design factors.

Cavity Size and Shape

The most noticeable difference is the size and shape of the cavities.

  • Muffin pans have larger, deeper cups to allow the batter to rise into a domed shape. Their straight sides and angled edges promote an all-around even rise.
  • Cupcake cavities are wider but shallower. Their tapered, cup-like shape encourages batter to rise higher in the center but gentler around the edges, creating the signature mounded cupcake shape.

Tip: Muffin pans work best for denser, heavier batters that need room to rise. Cupcake pans suit lighter, more delicate batters that don’t rise as much.

Capacity and Sizing

Both pans come in a range of cavity counts to suit different needs:

  • Standard sizes include 6, 12 or 24 count pans. Great for everyday baking needs.
  • Mini pans have 36 to 80 smaller cavities for bite-sized treats.
  • Jumbo muffin pans boast oversized cups for epic muffins packed with mix-ins.

Key Takeaway: Choose your pan capacity based on the quantity and size of goods you want to bake.

Design Variations

While cups in a cupcake pan maintain a uniform shape and size, muffin pans can vary:

  • Standard muffin pans have straight sides and flat rims.
  • Waffle pans have indented rims to maximize the domed shape.
  • Non-stick and silicone muffin pans make unmolding easy.

Consider your recipe’s special needs when selecting a pan material and design.

Choosing the Right Pan

Now that you know their differences, here are some tips for choosing pans:

  • For a fluffy batter that needs to rise high, use a cupcake pan.
  • Heavy, dense batters suit muffin pans better to achieve the signature dome shape.
  • Mini pans work well for both as you can make mini muffins and cupcakes.
  • For a pretty presentation, opt for cupcake pans that you can line with bright liners.
  • Muffin pans excel at breads and quickbreads that rise nicely into the deep cups.

Key Takeaway: Consider the batter consistency and desired results to decide between muffin pans vs. cupcake pans.

Working with Muffin and Cupcake Batters

The type of batter you use impacts results based on the pan. Here are some tips for adapting batters when using muffin vs cupcake pans:

Muffin Batter

Muffin batter contains more fat and sugar to give muffins their cakey texture and dome shape. To bake muffins in a cupcake pan:

  • Slightly reduce fat and sugar so batter rises less.
  • Fill cups 2/3 full and bake 5 minutes less than usual.
  • Remove from pan ASAP after baking or the muffin tops may stick.

Cupcake Batter

Cupcake batter has a lighter, fluffier consistency with less fat and sugar. Baking it in a muffin pan requires a few tweaks:

  • Increase fat and sugar slightly to help batter rise higher to fill the tall cups.
  • Fill cups 3/4 full and bake 5 minutes more than usual.
  • Let cool completely before removing to allow cupcakes to shrink away from pan sides.

Using Liners

While cupcake liners fit nicely into muffin pans, the opposite may not hold true. Here are some liner tips:

  • Standard muffin liners are too large for most cupcake pans. Opt for mini liners instead.
  • Foil liners are more flexible and work for both cupcakes and muffins.
  • For a perfect fit, look for liners specifically designed for your pan.
  • Grease or spray pans well if baking directly into the cups.

Key Takeaway: Test different liner sizes to find the ideal fit for your chosen pan.

Baking Tips and FAQs

Get the most out of your pans with these pro tips and answers to common questions:

Preventing Sticking and Overflow

Sticking and overflow easily ruin muffins and cupcakes. Avoid problems with these tips:

  • Always grease or line pans well.
  • For liners, use ones specifically made to fit your pan.
  • Check batter consistency – too thin can overflow, too thick can stick.
  • Fill cups 2/3 full for muffins, 3/4 full for cupcakes.

Ensuring Even Baking

Patchy browning or uncooked centers? Fix it with:

  • Position pans evenly spaced on oven racks.
  • Rotate pans halfway through baking to prevent hot spots.
  • Allow 2 inches around pans for air circulation.

Troubleshooting Issues

Domed or cracked muffin tops? Fill cups less and bake 5 minutes less.

Dense, sinking cupcake centers? Make batter lighter and bake 5 minutes more.

Uneven browning? Rotate pan and bake at slightly lower temp.

Sticking? Grease well and remove from pan ASAP after baking.


While muffin pans and cupcake pans appear similar, each works best for their intended recipes thanks to differences in size, shape and ideal batter consistency. With the right techniques and batter adjustments, both types of pans can produce top-notch results for muffins, cupcakes and more. Knowing how to troubleshoot issues like sticking and uneven baking helps ensure baking success.

Now that you know how to choose pans and adapt batters, you can enjoy perfectly domed muffins and delicate, decadent cupcakes baked just the way you like them!

FAQs About muffin pan vs cupcake pan

Can you use cupcake liners in a muffin pan?

Yes, you can use cupcake liners in a muffin pan. In fact, many people prefer to use cupcake liners when baking muffins, as they help to prevent the muffins from sticking to the pan and make them easier to remove.

Are the batters for muffins and cupcakes the same?

No, the batters for muffins and cupcakes are not the same.

What are pros and cons of silicone muffin pans?

Silicone muffin pans have a number of pros and cons. Pros:
Non-stick: Silicone is naturally non-stick, so you don’t need to grease or flour the pan before baking. This makes it easy to remove the muffins from the pan after they are baked.
Flexible: The silicone is flexible, so it is easy to bend the pan to remove the muffins. This is also helpful if you need to store the pan in a small space.
Oven-safe: Silicone muffin pans can be used in the oven, freezer, and microwave. This makes them versatile and easy to clean.
Durable: Silicone is a durable material that can withstand high temperatures. This means that your silicone muffin pan will last for many years.
Not as heat-conducting as metal: Silicone is not as heat-conducting as metal, so your muffins may not brown as evenly.
More expensive: Silicone muffin pans are typically more expensive than metal muffin pans.
Can be difficult to clean: If your silicone muffin pan is not properly cleaned, it can become stained.

How do you prevent cupcakes and muffins from sticking to the pan?

There are a few things you can do to prevent cupcakes and muffins from sticking to the pan:
Grease or spray the pan with non-stick cooking spray. This will help to create a barrier between the batter and the pan, preventing the muffins from sticking.
Use cupcake liners. Cupcake liners are a great way to prevent muffins from sticking to the pan. They also make it easy to remove the muffins from the pan after they are baked.
Fill the cups of the pan only two-thirds full. This will give the muffins enough room to rise without overflowing the cups and sticking to the sides of the pan.
Don’t overbake the muffins. Overbaked muffins will be dry and more likely to stick to the pan.
Let the muffins cool completely before removing them from the pan. This will help to loosen the muffins from the pan and make them easier to remove.

Share your love

Richard Charpentier is the CEO of Baking Innovation, a leading provider of baking solutions. He has over 20 years of experience in the baking industry and has been a driving force behind the company's success.